Alanine-based peptides of defined sequence and length show measurable helix contents, allowing them to be used as a model system both for analyzing the mechanism of helix formation and for investigating the contributions of side-chain interactions to protein stability. Extensive characterization of many peptide sequences with varying amino acid contents indicates that the favorable helicity of alanine-based peptides can be attributed to the large helix-stabilizing propensity of alanine. The resulting model provides a physically plausible resolution of the discrepancies between the two systems and allows the helix contents of both template-nucleated and standard peptide helices to be predicted by using a single set of helix propensities. Helix formation in both standard peptides and template-peptide conjugates can be attributed to the large intrinsic helix-forming tendency of alanine.The energetic cost of ␣-helix nucleation generally is considered to originate from the requirement of constraining the conformation of three consecutive amino acids before the first helical hydrogen bond can form (1). In contrast, helix propagation requires only one additional residue to be constrained for the formation of one additional hydrogen bond. The overall extent of helix formation depends on the energetics of both nucleation and propagation, as well as on chain length. To separate the effects of helix nucleation and propagation experimentally, Kemp and coworkers (2, 3) have designed a template (Ac-Hel 1 ; see Fig. 1A) that overcomes the nucleation penalty for helix formation by providing hydrogen-bond acceptors for the otherwise unsatisfied NH groups at the N terminus of the helix. Short peptides attached to this template show significant helix formation that is nucleated preferentially from the template. Because the template efficiently nucleates helical segments, the macroscopic characteristics of the template-nucleated helix depend primarily on the nucleation properties of the template and the propagation propensities of the attached amino acid residues.Using the Ac-Hel 1 template as both a nucleation site and a reporter of helix content, Kemp and coworkers (2, 4-6) have reported significant helix formation for a number of short alanine-based peptide sequences under a variety of conditions. Quite surprisingly, however, the authors conclude from their data that alanine is helix-indifferent with an equilibrium constant for propagation of approximately one (2, 4). In direct contrast, alanine is observed to be a strong helix former in a variety of standard peptide systems (7-9). To explain this paradox, Kemp and coworkers (2) have suggested that the helix content of standard alanine-based peptides might originate from an anomalously large nucleation propensity of alanine. A large nucleation propensity is inconsistent, however, with the extent of fraying observed in alanine-based peptides (10-12). Furthermore, to model their Ac-Hel 1 -peptide conjugate data, Kemp and coworkers (2, 4-6) assume that the nucleation propen...