Food in transition: The place of food in the theories of transition

Abstract

Among the different theories used to explain social change, the transition theory holds a special place. It has been applied to subjects such as demography, epidemiology, nutrition, etc. and most often from a multidisciplinary perspective. However, beyond the apparent uniqueness of the transition label there are quite different theoretical frameworks and presuppositions, which can be a source of misunderstanding. A first perspective considers change as the transition from one stable state to another and concentrates on the processes at work in the transition phase. It focuses attention on the interactions between cultural and biological variables and tries to take into account the consequences of the fact that they move at different rates. A second perspective conceives change as a series of stages (more or less stable situations) and proceeds to analyse the structural transformation of the organisation at each stage. The emphasis is placed on the transformations that take place during these stages. This brings us closer to the theory of stages. Finally, a third perspective combines stages and transitions. Change is seen as part of an evolutionary and progressive movement and as being reversible or not. This article studies the cognitive organisation of the different theoretical variants of the transition model in which food plays a more or less important role.

The Malaysian Food Barometer Open Database: An Invitation to Study the Modernization of Malaysian Food Patterns and Its Economic and Health Consequences

“…Compacted modernity is characterized by some sociodemographic transformations, linked to the demographic transition like rapid urbanization, decrease of fertility, and reduction in the size of the household including some socioeconomic changes like increase in purchasing power and emergence of a middle class ( 9 , 10 ). The epidemiological transition can be referred to as changes and the causes of mortality from epidemic diseases to cardiovascular diseases, cancers, and degenerative diseases ( 11 – 13 ). All these structural transformations have affected the lifestyles and the food habits of the various ethnic groups, which make the Malaysian population ( 14 ).…”

Evolving Food Choices Among the Urban Indian Middle-Class: A Qualitative Study

“…In modern urban society, energy needs are low, however, the values governing food and eating still stay rooted in an earlier stage and link quantity and abundance with prosperity and celebration. There is a lag in the transformation of value systems to fit with contemporary energy needs, which is referred to as the obesity transition ( 69 ). This transition is related to socio-economic position as energy needs change.…”

Australian Generation Z and the Nexus between Climate Change and Alternative Proteins

“…Transition theories have been used in the past to explain changes in people’s behaviour in relation to food. This includes nutrition/protein transition theory which highlights the shift from plant- to animal-based foods initially and, in recent times, the reverse—from animal- to plant-based foods [ 61 , 62 , 63 ]. Aiking and de Boer [ 64 ] explain that alternative proteins would form part of the expected protein transition because of increased environmental and health awareness.…”