Food and beverage price discounts to improve health in remote Aboriginal communities: mixed method evaluation of a natural experiment

Abstract

Objective: Retrospectively evaluate food price discounts in remote Aboriginal community stores. Methods:Four price discount strategies of 10% were designed in 2010, aiming to influence grocery, fruit, vegetables and diet soft-drink sales. This natural experiment across a group of stores was evaluated using an explanatory, sequential mixed method design through analysis of store point-of-sale, document, observation and interview data. The outcome was measured by change in: 1) percentage of grocery sales to total food and beverage; 2) fruit and vegetable sales; and 3) diet soft-drink sales. Qualitative data enabled the interpretation of outcomes through understanding perceived success and benefits, and enablers and barriers to implementation. Results:Eighteen community stores and 54 informants participated. While targeted price discounts were considered important to improving health, no discernible effect was evident, due to inadequate design and communication of discount promotion, and probably inadequate magnitude of discount. Conclusions:Strategy impact on food and beverage sales was limited by promotion and magnitude of discount. Implication for Public Health:This study demonstrates key factors and commitment required to design, communicate, implement and monitor strategies to improve health in this challenging remote retail context. Evaluation of natural experiments can contribute evidence to policy-making.

Investigating business outcomes of healthy food retail strategies: A systematic scoping review

“…The majority of studies were conducted in the United States (n = 56) or Canada (n = 13) . Studies encompassed food service (n = 44), grocery (n = 56), and mixed (n = 7) retail settings including cafeterias (n = 24), full service restaurants (n = 18), corner stores and/or grocery stores (n = 19), supermarkets (n = 16), vending machines (n = 13), quick‐service restaurants (n = 13), and cafés (n = 5) . Approximately half of thes...…”

“…Six initiatives were retailer‐led, 29 were the result of partnerships, and 41 were researcher‐led, with the remainder government‐, industry‐, or health organization‐led. More than half of the included studies (n = 66) identified one or more business outcomes in the primary aim of the study.…”

What do we know about the diets of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in Australia? A systematic literature review

“…This energy–cost differential helps explain the persistently poor dietary patterns reported in this population 43 . Despite this, research suggests that community dietary patterns can be improved through improved food supply and stock management in community stores 45,46 . Consequently, the focus of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander nutrition‐based initiatives has broadened to include improving food quality and access to healthy food in remote communities, 45,46 rather than a sole focus on nutrition education.…”

Implementing healthy food policies in health services: A qualitative study

“…5,6 However, sustainable, at-scale uptake of these policies has been limited in part because of the current paucity of research identifying factors which drive successful implementation. Within the existing literature, there has been some exploration of the experiences of retailers involved in healthy food interventions, [7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17] and some research drawing on researchers' own experiences of implementation. 7,8,16,18 However, there is little literature capturing the comprehensive experiences of implementation, across the range of stakeholders involved in designing and implementing the policy.…”