Gelation by small molecules is enormously topical in catalysis, nanomaterials, drug delivery, and pharmaceutical crystallization. The way in which gelators selforganize to give a 3D gel network is poorly understood. How does a system progress from a continuous pattern of supramolecular motifs to a network of fibers with well-defined morphologies? Why are gel fibers so homogeneous, and why do they form instead of crystals? This work shows, predictively, that gels arise by the scrolling of sheets with asymmetric surface structures.