Recently, Yu and co-workers reported the observation of hot luminescence for Mn 2+ in 3.6 nm ZnS nanocrystals, implying that the phonon relaxation rates in nanocrystals were B10 6 times lower than that in bulk materials. In order to verify this unexpected observation, we investigated the time-resolved spectroscopy of 4.5 nm ZnS:Mn 2+ nanocrystals. Samples with two different Mn 2+ concentrations were studied. In contradiction with the results reported by Yu and co-workers, no evidence of Mn 2+ hot luminescence was found, regardless of the Mn 2+ concentration, temperature (4.2-300 K), time delay (0.1-1000 ms), gate width (2-3000 ms), or excitation density (40-700 mJ/cm 2 ).