Flooding and the framing of risk in British broadsheets, 1985–2010

Abstract

Our analysis of 2707 news stories explores the framing of flooding over the past quarter century and the displacement of a once dominant understanding of flooding as an agricultural problem of land drainage by the contemporary concern for its urban impacts, particularly to homes and property. We document dramatic changes in the volume and variety of reporting about flooding since 2000 as the risks of flooding have become more salient, the informal 'Gentlemen's Agreement' between government and private insurers has broken down, and flood management subjected to greater public scrutiny. While the historic reliance on private insurance remains largely unchallenged, we show that other aspects of flood hazard management are now topics of active political debate to which the looming threat of climate change adds both urgency and exculpatory excuses for poor performance. We conclude by reflecting on the significance of the case for grand theories of neoliberalization and governmentality.

Evaluating media framing and public reactions in the context of a water reuse proposal

“…the online comments), again, framing analysis concepts were employed using the definition that 'a framing effect occurs when audiences pay substantial attention to news messages' (Scheufele & Tewksbury, 2007). This stage of analysis sought to qualitatively examine whether there was evidence that the media frames, considered as an independent variable, could be said to resonate with popular knowledge (Escobar & Demeritt, 2014) and, more specifically, to influence the responses (Scheufele, 1999). Drawing on pattern-matching techniques (Yin, 2012), the proposition was that a framing effect would be indicated if similar patterns of themes and relative strength of sentiment (as coded) were observed between the articles and comments, across the cases.…”

A media framing analysis of urban flooding in Nigeria: current narratives and implications for policy

“…This perspective has recently sparked a fertile area of research in respect of media framing around recent flooding events to understand policy (Bohensky and Leitch 2014;Devitt and O'Neill 2017;Escobar and Demeritt 2014;Haider-Markel et al 2007). However, the majority of these studies are for cities in developed regions, whilst far less is known about how flooding issues are framed within local and national media in developing countries and the consequent policy implications.…”

Enriching Great Britain's National Landslide Database by searching newspaper archives

“…Analysis of the interactions between mass media coverage and public understanding of hazards and risk can be performed (Kasperson et al, 1988). For example, media coverage of a particular hazard can be assessed over time to understand changes in how issues such as responsibility are framed (Escobar and Demeritt, 2014) or assessing variation in interest in a particular story over time (Carvalho, 2007).…”