Fleeting Substantiality: The Samoan Giant in US Popular Discourse

Abstract

In this article I draw examples from the broader terrain of academic and popular literature, news media, television, and film to explore questions regarding representations of Samoans, and especially Samoan men, in the United States. The mediated accessibility of Samoans, via televised sports and entertainment, combines with their relative geographic and demographic inaccessibility to produce popular images of a population that the vast majority of Americans know very little about. Such representations are gendered in particular ways, such that the archetypal Samoan body in US popular discourse is now masculine, rather than feminine. I discuss how popular representations of Samoan men may be similar to representations of black men—the latter so central to discourses of race in the United States—as well as how are they different, particularly in light of the discursively slippery histories of representing Pacific peoples as both noble and ignoble “savages.” The main narrative component of discourses about Samoan men, body size, is critically engaged; additionally, the article argues that the added element of (indigenous) culture—thought to be outside or anterior to Western modernity—grant to Samoans an exoticness not normally granted to black Americans. This essay attempts to expose, engage, and examine these active processes of representation and myth creation—what visual theorist Clyde Taylor might term mythogenesis—to better understand the discursive terrain that Samoans negotiate, often ambivalently in the United States.

Moving materialities: Oceanic epistemologies and embodied knowledge production in Pentecostal women's health mentorship in Samoa

“…This is especially important as large “Polynesian” bodies have been racialized as ignorant, primitive, and lazy and islands like Samoa are quickly glossed in media, scholarly publication, and policy as some of the “fattest nations” on earth (cf. Henderson, 2011; Hobart and Maroney, 2019). Critically examining dance also speaks to the enduring sexualization and commodification of “Polynesian” women and the central role that these essentialized ideas play in the ongoing dispossession of Indigenous people in Oceania (see Imada, 2012; Trask, 1999).…”

Coconut Oil Reflects: A Comparative Commodity Ethnography In Two Sites

“…In the continental United States, Pacific culture may be visible in popular culture but Islanders, with a handful of exceptions in sports and entertainment, generally are not (Henderson, 2011). Bonnie Pauahi Tysse (Bay Area, Hawaiian) describes this dynamic as "being seen and unseen at the same time."…”

“…This means that many Bay Area Islanders are (mis)read as Hispanic or Latino, black or African American, Asian, or white (Henderson, 2011;M. Perez, 2002), though this may also have to do with the fact that Islanders living in the United States are the most likely racial group in the country to identify themselves as belonging to two or more races (Duncan, 2012).…”