Fiscal Transparency: Concepts, Measurement and UK Practice

Abstract

Greater fiscal transparency is seen by its advocates as a means of improving economic governance arrangements in ways which, by promoting fiscal stability, will in turn improve the functioning of the government sector and facilitate improvements in the economic environment for the private sector. 'Fiscal transparency' is much acclaimed by policy-makers, not only in the UK Treasury but also by the IMF and OECD. Fiscal transparency can have substance or can just be voguish incantation. This article explores the meaning of fiscal transparency, by examining its structure and evaluating criteria for assessing the degree of fiscal transparency attached to particular sets of circumstances. It explores the link between transparency and accountability, developing the distinction between event and process transparency. Consideration is given to the trade-off between the value of sunlight (to employ an analogy) and the danger of over-exposure. The performance of the United Kingdom against emerging international best practice is examined, with regard to both public expenditure and taxation. By international standards, UK fiscal transparency is high. Nevertheless, there is a major gap between UK rhetoric and practice, indicating a divergence between nominal and effective transparency. This is evidenced by: frequent changes in public expenditure definitions; the non-publication of important analyses; the location of certain liabilities 'off-balance sheet'; and a lack of candour about tax policy.

Budget Transparency in Local Governments: An Empirical Analysis

“…In particular, we tried to construct items to go beyond nominal fiscal transparency to measure effective transparency, as well (Heald 2003(Heald , 2006. The item selection was aimed at covering all the areas of budget content and budgetary process, but avoiding redundancy.…”

Avaliação da capacidade de gestão democrática em municípios baianos

“…partir dos anos 90 do século passado, passando a integrar, defi nitivamente, a agenda governamental (HEALD, 2003).…”

Building a clean government in Turkey: pillars, perils, and prospects

“…Justice system Traditionally, corruption in justice system has not been a major problem, but there are problematic arrangements for truly independent judiciary that need a radical overhaul ( [38]: [19][20][21][22][23][24]. Judges, public prosecutors and judicial inspectors that are responsible for evaluating the performance of judges and prosecutors are attached to the Ministry of Justice in terms of administrative functions.…”