“…From Figure 4, we can see clearly that with the decrease of the electronegativity difference between oxygen and substitutional elements, (N, C, and B), the impurity states become closer to the VBM. In addition, when the charges are balanced, the electron donors (H) may contribute to the lowering of the energy levels related to the acceptors (N, C, and B), resulting in the impurity states downward to the VBM, which agrees well with the previous studies [40]. Accordingly, the N : H species may enhance the mixing of impurity states induced by N 2p states and O 2p atomic orbitals in the VBM, and finally new valence bands can be formed, which could contribute to the formation of the band-band transition, in favor of the visible-light-driven catalytic activities.…”