Finding logic models for sustainable marine development that deliver on social equity

Ota, Yoshitaka; Singh, Gerald G.; Clark, Timothy P.; Schutter, Marleen S.; Swartz, Wilf; Cisneros‐Montemayor, Andrés M.

doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3001841

Cited by 12 publications

(10 citation statements)

References 87 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Policy goals are general ideas at the macro‐level governing policy development, which are a basic and fundamental component of any public policy (Howlett & Cashore, 2009, 2014; Petek et al, 2021). Compared to other policy goals such as economic efficiency and environmental sustainability, social equity goals are often not clearly specified in public policies and are lacking appropriate evaluative measures (e.g., see the discussion of integrating social equity in transportation policy goals by Manaugh et al (2015) and in sustainable marine development policy goals by Ota et al (2022)). For renewable energy policies, the three “E” goals (secure energy supply, reduce environmental pollution, and economic affordability) are often examined in the literature (Komor & Bazilian, 2005; Schmidt et al, 2019; Shen et al, 2011), while not much attention has been on social equity goals.…”

Section: Integrating Equity In Public Policy Designmentioning

confidence: 99%

Operationalizing social equity in public policy design: A comparative analysis of solar equity policies in the United States

Zhou

Gao

Wellstead

et al. 2023

Policy Studies Journal

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

While it is widely recognized that energy injustices are prevalent in the clean energy transition process, there has been limited research attention on policy efforts aiming to mitigate these inequities. In this paper, we use solar equity policies as an empirical case study to understand how social equity considerations are conceptualized and operationalized in energy policy content. We build upon the policy design literature and code institutional statements of 54 solar equity policies adopted between 2001 and 2021 in the United States. In our comparative analysis, we focus on three levels of policy design elements that can be directly observed in written policy language: macro‐policy goal construction, meso‐policy instrument choices, and micro‐level policy settings and calibrations. We find that the policy goal of energy justice is multifaceted, with a great emphasis on solar energy accessibility and provision of economic benefits and security for disadvantaged communities. There is a dominant preference by policymakers to use redistributive policies and community solar programs to advance energy justice‐related goals. Solar equity policy instruments on‐the‐ground measures have also been calibrated to target specific disadvantaged populations in the energy system, which focus mostly on income‐based vulnerability.

show abstract

Section: Integrating Equity In Public Policy Designmentioning

confidence: 99%

Operationalizing social equity in public policy design: A comparative analysis of solar equity policies in the United States

Zhou

Gao

Wellstead

et al. 2023

Policy Studies Journal

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…The notion of sustainable economic development signifies a substantial paradigm shift in our approach to growth and progress. It is a response to the crucial challenges posed by traditional development models that frequently prioritize economic growth at the cost of environmental health and social equity [1]. It integrates economic, environmental, and social considerations, aiming for a balance of long-term sustainability and fairness [2].…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

The evolution of sustainable economic development: Trends, trade-offs and trajectories for balanced economic activities

Wang,

Zheng

2024

Sustain. Econ.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This study presents a systematic examination of the paradigm shift towards mechanisms facilitating sustainable economic development, which has been instigated by the recognized deficiencies in conventional growth models pertaining to social, environmental, and economic dimensions. The discourse encompasses critical topics, including sustainable growth policies, environmental economics, sustainable entrepreneurship, poverty reduction strategies, green marketing and branding, and sustainable tourism. While discernible progress has been achieved, persistent challenges in areas such as inequality, climate change, resource management, and poverty necessitate further scrutiny. Future research endeavors may delve into understanding the motivations shaping sustainable development mechanisms, refining metrics to assess the impact of environmental entrepreneurship, and formulating strategies to address the intricate challenges associated with multifaceted poverty reduction. This shift towards balanced economic activities that promote environmental and social wellbeing is indispensable. Systematic, sustainable transformation encompassing governance, empowerment, renewable energy, and investments aligned with socio-ecological goals is imperative. And the impetus for sustainability integration is currently propelled by technological innovation, evolving consumer preferences, and widespread adoption across diverse sectors. This evolution signifies a collaborative trajectory to strike a delicate balance between economic growth and ecological limits for an equitable and sustainable development mechanism in the future.

show abstract

“…Some, for instance, emphasize conservation, ocean protection, or innovation and new technology (Voyer et al, 2018). Others focus on the economic, social, and political promotion of marginalized groups, thus bringing them in line with the emphasis on "no one left behind" (Ota et al, 2022) found in the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (for example see, Voyer et al, 2018;Fusco et al, 2022).…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Equity zombies in Canada’s blue economy: a critical feminist analysis for equitable policy implementation

Knott,

Fusco,

Daly

et al. 2024

Front. Mar. Sci.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

IntroductionOcean equity is a key aim of blue economy frameworks globally and is a pillar of the international High Level Panel for A Sustainable Ocean Economy. However, the Panel offers only a general definition of ocean equity, with limited guidance for countries. Canada, as a party to the High Level Panel’s blue economy agenda, is developing its own blue economy strategy, seeking to reshape its ocean-based industries and advocate for new ones. How equity will be incorporated across scales is not yet known but has implications for how countries like Canada will develop their ocean-based industries. This raises important questions, including what are Canada’s equity commitments in relation to its blue economy and how will they be met? Currently, the industries identified in Canada’s emerging blue economy narratives are governed through both federal and provincial legislation and policies. These will shape how equity is implemented at different scales.MethodsIn this paper, we examine how the term equity is defined in relevant federal and provincial legislation and look to how understandings of equity found in critical feminist, environmental justice, and climate justice scholarship could inform policy and its implementation within Canada’s blue economy. We focus on two industries that are important for Canada’s blue economy: offshore oil and marine salmon aquaculture in the Canadian province of Newfoundland and Labrador. We investigate how existing legislation and policy shapes the characterization, incorporation, and implementation of equity in these industries.Results and discussionOur analysis highlights how a cohesive approach to ocean equity across the scales of legislation and policy is needed to ensure more robust engagement with social and environmental equity issues in blue economy discourse and implementation.

show abstract

Finding logic models for sustainable marine development that deliver on social equity

Cited by 12 publications

References 87 publications

Operationalizing social equity in public policy design: A comparative analysis of solar equity policies in the United States

Operationalizing social equity in public policy design: A comparative analysis of solar equity policies in the United States

The evolution of sustainable economic development: Trends, trade-offs and trajectories for balanced economic activities

Equity zombies in Canada’s blue economy: a critical feminist analysis for equitable policy implementation

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About