Financial analysts' reaction to voluntary integrated reporting: cross-sectional variation in institutional enforcement contexts

Abstract

PurposeEuropean countries are likely to increasingly adopt integrated reporting (IR) voluntarily, after the 2014/95/EU Directive is revised and other initiatives are implemented. Therefore, the present study provides insights on the relevance of IR in voluntary contexts by exploring analysts' reactions to the release of integrated reports in diverse institutional settings.Design/methodology/approachDrawing on voluntary disclosure theory, a quantitative empirical research method is used to explore the moderating role of country-level institutional characteristics on the associations between voluntary IR release and analyst forecast accuracy and dispersion.FindingsIR informativeness is not uniform in the voluntary context and institutional settings play a moderating role. IR release is associated with increased consensus among analyst forecasts. However, in countries with weak institutional enforcement, a reverse association is detected, indicating that analysts rely largely on IR where the institutional setting strongly protects investors. Although a strong institutional setting boosts the IR release usefulness in terms of accuracy, it creates noise in analyst consensus.Research limitations/implicationsAcademics can appreciate the usefulness of voluntary IR across the institutional enforcement contexts.Practical implicationsManagers can use these findings to understand opportunities offered by IR voluntary release. The study recommends that policymakers, standard setters and regulators strengthen the institutional enforcement of sustainability disclosure.Originality/valueThis study is a unique contribution to recent calls for research on the effects of nonfinancial disclosure regulation and on IR “impacts”. It shows on the international scale that IR usefulness for analysts is moderated by institutional patterns, not country-level institutional characteristics.

The quality assessment of stakeholder engagement disclosure in the EU mandatory non-financial reporting framework

“…The role of the legal frameworks in pushing to more effective forms of sustainability reporting is a topic of interest not only in the European context (Cupertino et al, 2022;Dumitru et al, 2017;Mion and Adaui, 2019;Venturelli et al, 2019;Zanellato and Tiron-Tudor, 2022) but also in other countries or territorial contexts. With reference to the worldwide situation, Krueger et al (2023) showed that a compulsory ESG disclosure regulation can contribute to the improvement of corporate information, with general benefits on the capital market, particularly by helping reduce differences and therefore protecting the interests of JAAR 25,1 investors (Rossignoli et al, 2022). Other studies involving extra-European countries (Syed and Butt, 2017;Tran et al, 2021) confirm that a regulatory framework that seeks to consider the interests of stakeholders, particularly investors, can constitute a positive opportunity for the development of more complete and adequate practices of sustainability reporting (Alshbili and Elamer, 2020;Sadou et al, 2017).…”

“…With reference to the worldwide situation, Krueger et al. (2023) showed that a compulsory ESG disclosure regulation can contribute to the improvement of corporate information, with general benefits on the capital market, particularly by helping reduce differences and therefore protecting the interests of investors (Rossignoli et al. , 2022).…”

Guest editorial Rethinking non-financial reporting in Europe: challenges and opportunities in revising Directive 2014/95/EU

“…Financial analysts' reaction to voluntary integrated reporting: cross-sectional variation in institutional enforcement contexts Drawing on voluntary disclosure theory, Rossignoli et al (2022) conducted a quantitative empirical research study to explore the moderating role of country-level institutional characteristics on the associations between voluntary IR release and analyst forecast accuracy and dispersion. The study demonstrates that financial analysts rely on IR to predict earnings per share, in particular, where the institutional enforcement is strong.…”

Sustainable development, disclosure to stakeholders and the Sustainable Development Goals: Evidence from Brazilian banks' non‐financial reports

“…Non‐financial disclosure through environmental, social, integrated or sustainability reports in addition to expanding the number of information disclosed to stakeholders, also greatly expands the target audience of such information (Raimo et al, 2021). There is a trend in Europe, for instance, in the increase of the number of voluntary disclosure of the integrated type (Rossignoli et al, 2022).…”