Single crystal diamond nanotips reveal a new behavior for ultrafast laser-induced electron emission. Under tightly focused femtosecond laser illumination, electron yield shows a saturation with the laser intensity. When the DC bias is sufficient for dark field emission, large optical intensities can switch off the emission occurring between laser pulses during a few hundred μs, because of the low conductance of the diamond tip. We propose a macroscopic model to combine a capacitive effect with the different conduction and emission mechanisms. This study shows that non-metallic photocathodes offer different perspectives from the conventional metallic ones.