“…Tourmaline analyses with elevated and reliable determination of Fe 3+ /Fe tot only rarely yield Fe 3+ PFe 2+ or even Fe 3+ /Fe tot P $30% (see e.g., Dyar et al, 1998;Taran and Rossman, 2002;Bačík et al, 2008;Baksheev et al, 2011;Novák et al, 2011), disregarding the studies on "buergerite" and povondraite from their type localities. Schorl from Silver Crater with 2.04 apfu Fe 3+ , 1.73 apfu Fe 2+ , 1.28 apfu Mg and 3.52 apfu Al tot , dravite from Bronson Station with 0.61 apfu Fe 3+ , 0.49 apfu Fe 2+ , 2.34 apfu Mg and 5.47 apfu Al tot -both from Hastings, Ontario (the same geological region as the Cancrinite Hill, Bancroft), dravite from Pierrepont, New York, with 0.69 apfu Fe 3+ , 0.31 apfu Fe 2+ , 2.70 apfu Mg and 5.29 apfu Al tot , and dravite from Montezuma, Mexico, with 0.98 apfu Fe 3+ , 0.70 apfu Fe 2+ , 1.86 apfu Mg and 5.47 apfu Al tot , all exhibit very high Fe 3+ contents.…”