Abstract:We studied the effect of felbamate (FBM) monotherapy on seizure rate in patients with partial and secondarily generalized seizures undergoing presurgical monitoring at a single site. The study design was a double-blind placebo-controlled parallel monotherapy trial. Forty patients whose seizures had not been controlled by standard antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) were randomized. Seizure type was confirmed by video-EEG monitoring. All baseline AEDs were discontinued, and patients were drug-free for 5.3 +/- 2.4 days b… Show more
“…6 (70). Two FBM patients dropped out because of meeting seizure exit criteria, and six, because of side effects, whereas in the placebo group, 10 patients dropped out because of meeting seizure exit criteria, and one, for side effects (Fig.…”
Section: What Are the Available Monotherapy Designs That Have Been Usmentioning
confidence: 91%
“…Proportion of felbamate (FBM) versus placebo (PBO) patients remaining in the NIH presurgical monotherapy trial(70).…”
What is the clinical rationale for using AEDs in monotherapy? (Adapted from a talk by Jacqueline French, M.D.) Monotherapy has multiple advantages over polytherapy, including fewer side effects and drug-drug interactions, better patient compliance, less teratogenicity, and lower cost. Schmidt (1) demonstrated that when patients receiving standard polytherapy had one drug removed, 83% maintained the previous level of seizure control, 36% had fewer seizures, and 5% became seizure free. In addition, side effects decreased. Similarly, studies by Schmidt (2) and Mattson et al. (3) revealed that a second AED adds only marginal benefit. In their studies, only 11-13% of patients had a substantial decrease in seizures, and side effects increased.FDA monotherapy approval is particularly important for the newer AEDs, which have potential advantages of better tolerability, improved safety, less teratogenicity, and simpler pharmacokinetics, which cannot be realized when the new drugs are combined with older drugs that do not share these advantages. In addition, it is established practice to treat newly diagnosed patients with a single drug; therefore absence of a monotherapy license precludes anything but off-label use of new AEDs as initial therapy. Currently, prescribing these drugs as "offlabel" can present obstacles to insurance reimbursement and increase physician concern regarding legal liability.
“…6 (70). Two FBM patients dropped out because of meeting seizure exit criteria, and six, because of side effects, whereas in the placebo group, 10 patients dropped out because of meeting seizure exit criteria, and one, for side effects (Fig.…”
Section: What Are the Available Monotherapy Designs That Have Been Usmentioning
confidence: 91%
“…Proportion of felbamate (FBM) versus placebo (PBO) patients remaining in the NIH presurgical monotherapy trial(70).…”
What is the clinical rationale for using AEDs in monotherapy? (Adapted from a talk by Jacqueline French, M.D.) Monotherapy has multiple advantages over polytherapy, including fewer side effects and drug-drug interactions, better patient compliance, less teratogenicity, and lower cost. Schmidt (1) demonstrated that when patients receiving standard polytherapy had one drug removed, 83% maintained the previous level of seizure control, 36% had fewer seizures, and 5% became seizure free. In addition, side effects decreased. Similarly, studies by Schmidt (2) and Mattson et al. (3) revealed that a second AED adds only marginal benefit. In their studies, only 11-13% of patients had a substantial decrease in seizures, and side effects increased.FDA monotherapy approval is particularly important for the newer AEDs, which have potential advantages of better tolerability, improved safety, less teratogenicity, and simpler pharmacokinetics, which cannot be realized when the new drugs are combined with older drugs that do not share these advantages. In addition, it is established practice to treat newly diagnosed patients with a single drug; therefore absence of a monotherapy license precludes anything but off-label use of new AEDs as initial therapy. Currently, prescribing these drugs as "offlabel" can present obstacles to insurance reimbursement and increase physician concern regarding legal liability.
“…One strategy to achieve approval for ''monotherapy'' involves inpatient drug withdrawal (standard during video-EEG monitoring to identify seizure foci in patients being considered for surgery) followed by addition of experimental drug or placebo [123]. This process is expensive, may have relatively higher risks of increased seizures, and does not necessarily mirror conventional clinical treatment due to the effects of baseline AED withdrawal.…”
Section: Development and Testing Of Aedsmentioning
Seizures can be caused by a wide range of brain disorders. Patients with two unprovoked seizures are considered to have epilepsy, and should receive antiepileptic drug treatment. The choice of drugs depends in part on diagnosis of the specific seizure syndrome, based on clinical, electroencephalographic, and neuroimaging data. Mechanisms of drugs action include modulation of voltage‐dependent neuronal ion channels, enhancement of GABA‐mediated inhibition, Inhibition of ionotropic glutamate receptor‐ mediated synaptic excitation, and modulation of glutamate release. Specific AED pharmacokinetics, particularly drug interactions, and toxicity, should be considered carefully in planning drug treatment. For patients with persistent seizures on optimal drug therapy, other options include diet, surgery, and brain stimulation.
“…In recent years, some monotherapy trials have been conducted, in restricted circumstances (264). For example, felbamate was studied in placebo-controlled monotherapy trials in patients following pre-surgical electroencephalographic and video monitoring (295)(296)(297). In these trials, the patients underwent intensive neurodiagnostic monitoring after partial or complete withdrawal from their prior AEDs.…”
Section: Other Challenges In Clinical Developmentmentioning
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.