Fatigue Induced by Repeated Changes of Direction in Élite Female Football (Soccer) Players: Impact on Lower Limb Biomechanics and Implications for ACL Injury Prevention

Abstract

BackgroundThe etiology of Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) injury in women football results from the interaction of several extrinsic and intrinsic risk factors. Extrinsic factors change dynamically, also due to fatigue. However, existing biomechanical findings concerning the impact of fatigue on the risk of ACL injuries remains inconsistent. We hypothesized that fatigue induced by acute workload in short and intense game periods, might in either of two ways: by pushing lower limbs mechanics toward a pattern close to injury mechanism, or alternatively by inducing opposed protective compensatory adjustments.AimIn this study, we aimed at assessing the extent to which fatigue impact on joints kinematics and kinetics while performing repeated changes of direction (CoDs) in the light of the ACL risk factors.MethodsThis was an observational, cross-sectional associative study. Twenty female players (age: 20–31 years, 1st–2nd Italian division) performed a continuous shuttle run test (5-m) involving repeated 180°-CoDs until exhaustion. During the whole test, 3D kinematics and ground reaction forces were used to compute lower limb joints angles and internal moments. Measures of exercise internal load were: peak post-exercise blood lactate concentration, heart rate (HR) and perceived exertion. Continuous linear correlations between kinematics/kinetics waveforms (during the ground contact phase of the pivoting limb) and the number of consecutive CoD were computed during the exercise using a Statistical Parametric Mapping (SPM) approach.ResultsThe test lasted 153 ± 72 s, with a rate of 14 ± 2 CoDs/min. Participants reached 95% of maximum HR and a peak lactate concentration of 11.2 ± 2.8 mmol/L. Exercise duration was inversely related to lactate concentration (r = −0.517, p < 0.01), while neither%HRmax nor [La–]b nor RPE were correlated with test duration before exhaustion (p > 0.05). Alterations in lower limb kinematics were found in 100%, and in lower limb kinetics in 85% of the players. The most common kinematic pattern was a concurrent progressive reduction in hip and knee flexion angle at initial contact (10 players); 5 of them also showed a significantly more adducted hip. Knee extension moment decreased in 8, knee valgus moment increased in 5 players. A subset of participants showed a drift of pivoting limb kinematics that matches the known ACL injury mechanism; other players displayed less definite or even opposed behaviors.DiscussionPlayers exhibited different strategies to cope with repeated CoDs, ranging from protective to potentially dangerous behaviors. While the latter was not a univocal effect, it reinforces the importance of individual biomechanical assessment when coping with fatigue.

Treatment Trends in Meniscal Pathology in the Setting of Concomitant ACL Injuries in Pediatric and Young Adult Patients: An Insurance Database Study

“…If we assume that the discrepancy in the relative frequency of meniscal procedures is not related to nonrandom differences in detection or indications for intervention, our findings likely reflect known biologic or mechanistic differences between male and female patients experiencing ACL rupture and potentially differences in energy during injury. For example, female athletes typically display differences in lower extremity biomechanics, 38 which may increase the risk of ACL rupture and demonstrate higher proportions of noncontact injuries versus male athletes among similar athletic activities. 7 Moreover, male athletes are at highest risk for experiencing ACL ruptures while playing American football, with injuries often occurring via player contact.…”

Team Approach: Neuromuscular Training for Primary and Secondary Prevention of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury

“…These athletic situations are typically limited to the team sports environment, given the increased nature of unplanned and reactionary athletic demands present in that environment. The prototypical—and must thoroughly studied 18-20 —setting for neuromuscular training is in the female soccer athlete. However, any sport with a high rate of cruciate ligament injury and potential for contested athletic movements represents an opportunity for neuromuscular training (Table I).…”

Influence of Fatigue on Cognitive-Motor Function During Unanticipated Landings

“…15,21,37 On the contrary, it has been demonstrated that a ligament failure event can occur after repetitive, harmful submaximal knee joint 5-in-5 loads, each causing enough microdamage to weaken the ligament's structural integrity. 6,36,46,51,52 This alternative point of view shifts fatigue, as a risk factor, toward a complex situation involving short and intense bouts of maneuvers that gradually increase the chance of incurring an ACL tear. 36,51 This scenario usually includes a combination of knee joint compression, knee flexion moment, anterior tibial shear force, internal tibial torque, and knee abduction moment, which collectively result in the greatest loads on the ACL.…”