Self-assembly of complex structures is commonplace in biology but often poorly understood. In the case of the actin cytoskeleton, a great deal is known about the components that include higher order structures, such as lamellar meshes, filopodial bundles, and stress fibers. Each of these cytoskeletal structures contains actin filaments and cross-linking proteins, but the role of cross-linking proteins in the initial steps of structure formation has not been clearly elucidated. We employ an optical trapping assay to investigate the behaviors of two actin crosslinking proteins, fascin and ␣-actinin, during the first steps of structure assembly. Here, we show that these proteins have distinct binding characteristics that cause them to recognize and cross-link filaments that are arranged with specific geometries. ␣-Actinin is a promiscuous cross-linker, linking filaments over all angles. It retains this flexibility after cross-links are formed, maintaining a connection even when the link is rotated. Conversely, fascin is extremely selective, only cross-linking filaments in a parallel orientation. Surprisingly, bundles formed by either protein are extremely stable, persisting for over 0.5 h in a continuous wash. However, using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching and fluorescence decay experiments, we find that the stable fascin population can be rapidly competed away by free fascin. We present a simple avidity model for this crosslink dissociation behavior. Together, these results place constraints on how cytoskeletal structures assemble, organize, and disassemble in vivo.The actin cytoskeleton forms and manages an array of diverse structures with regularity and precision. The same set of tools is used by all cells to many different ends; for example, muscle cells form sarcomeres and non-muscle cells form filopodia, lamellipodia, and stress fibers (1-8). Formation and maintenance of actin cytoskeletal structures are critical for proper cell functions and viability (9 -16), but the mechanisms of these actions are poorly understood.A great deal of work has been done examining how cytoskeletal proteins are regulated and how they are sorted within the cell. Although assembly of complex cytoskeletal structures is clearly essential for the proper mechanical behavior of the cell, the physical mechanisms driving their assembly are incompletely understood. Mechanisms have been proposed for formations of structures such as filopodia (17-19) and stress fibers (20,21). Filopodial nucleation is thought to occur by formation of the filopodial tip complex bringing together actin filament barbed ends, allowing local elongation leading to filopodial growth (17). A recent study using electron tomography has revealed that prior to filopodia nucleation at the plasma membrane of cultured fibroblasts, filaments in the lamellipodia can be observed in distinct pairs (22). The authors suggest these pairs may play a key role in filopodial nucleation. Stress fiber formation is proposed to function through the coalescence of actin bundle...