Family Physicians' Opinions and Attitudes to Three Clinical Practice Guidelines

Abstract

Background: Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) have been promoted as a strategy to measure and improve the quality of patient care. However, more effort has been expended on creating guidelines than implementing them. We surveyed family physicians about their knowledge of and attitudes toward 3 well-publicized CPGs.Methods: A survey questionnaire was sent to a national sample of 600 family physicians selected at random from a file from the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP).Results: After 2 mailings, the response rate was 71%. For each of the 3 guidelines, roughly 60% of respondents were familiar or somewhat familiar with the CPG. More than half of family physicians studied said they have changed their medical practices based on CPGs, and only 3% said they do not believe in guidelines and would not use them. Use of CPGs was lowest among physicians in solo practice and among those working in rural areas. However, no significant differences in CPG use or familiarity were noted based on number of years in practice. Many respondents indicated an interest in keeping CPGs current via the internet.Conclusions: Most American family physicians find CPGs to be helpful, and familiarity with them is fairly uniform across most subgroups studied.

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria in Noncatheterized Adults

“…2 Several studies evaluating physicians attitudes toward practice recommendations indicate that up to two-thirds of clinicians are unaware of practice guidelines, perceive adopting the practice guidelines as a challenge to autonomy, have diminished confidence in the professional organization, are confused regarding the guidelines, and in some instances have a greater concern with the adverse outcomes associated with not prescribing an antimicrobial more than with the risk of downstream complications of inappropriate prescribing. [65][66][67][68][69][70] Some investigators have suggested a multifaceted approach coupled with appropriate process outcome measures to address the issue of translational barriers to the acceptance of the IDSA ASB recommendations. The foundation of this multifaceted approach is the support by administrators and medical staff leadership.…”

Barriers to adherence to hypertension guidelines among GPs in southern Sweden: A survey

“…In order to be successful these guidelines should move clinical behaviour closer to the behaviours the guidelines recommend. Many GPs consider guidelines useful in clinical practice [14,15]. However, some physicians remain sceptical regarding guidelines [16].…”

An evaluation of community-based resources for management of diabetes-related foot disorders in an Australian population

“…12 Clinicians may be unaware of the existence of guidelines, or may not be oriented towards their use. 13,14 Podiatrists may not be familiar with the use of clinical guidelines as these have not traditionally been incorporated into undergraduate training in Australia.…”