False positives complicate ancient pathogen identifications using high-throughput shotgun sequencing

Abstract

BackgroundIdentification of historic pathogens is challenging since false positives and negatives are a serious risk. Environmental non-pathogenic contaminants are ubiquitous. Furthermore, public genetic databases contain limited information regarding these species. High-throughput sequencing may help reliably detect and identify historic pathogens.ResultsWe shotgun-sequenced 8 16th-century Mixtec individuals from the site of Teposcolula Yucundaa (Oaxaca, Mexico) who are reported to have died from the huey cocoliztli (‘Great Pestilence’ in Nahautl), an unknown disease that decimated native Mexican populations during the Spanish colonial period, in order to identify the pathogen. Comparison of these sequences with those deriving from the surrounding soil and from 4 precontact individuals from the site found a wide variety of contaminant organisms that confounded analyses. Without the comparative sequence data from the precontact individuals and soil, false positives for Yersinia pestis and rickettsiosis could have been reported.ConclusionsFalse positives and negatives remain problematic in ancient DNA analyses despite the application of high-throughput sequencing. Our results suggest that several studies claiming the discovery of ancient pathogens may need further verification. Additionally, true single molecule sequencing’s short read lengths, inability to sequence through DNA lesions, and limited ancient-DNA-specific technical development hinder its application to palaeopathology.

Childhood bone tuberculosis from Roman Pécs, Hungary

“…Given the technical difficulties of detecting pathogens in skeletal remains via this method (Campana et al, 2014), this result was not unexpected. Further analyses using genomic capture which has been shown to be successful in retrieving pathogen genomes from archaeological samples, could be conducted in the future (Bos et al, 2011;Bouwman et al, 2012).…”

Pick the Right Pocket. Sub‐sampling of Bone Sections to Investigate Diagenesis and DNA Preservation

“…Moreover, the sample with histological evidence of bioerosion YOR‐20 seems to display the greatest diversity of bacterial sequences recovered (Figure S3). However, given the complexities of environmental metagenomic analyses (Campana et al, ; Salter et al, ; Pedersen et al, ) these results should be interpreted with caution.…”

Intraspecific DNA contamination distorts subtle population structure in a marine fish: Decontamination of herring samples before restriction‐site associated sequencing and its effects on population genetic statistics

“…However, high‐throughput sequencing is sensitive to the contamination of samples with exogenous (nontarget) DNA. Errors introduced by interspecific DNA contamination have been identified in whole genome assemblies (Koutsovoulos et al, ; Longo, O'Neill, & O'Neill, ), ancient DNA (Campana, Robles García, Rühli, & Tuross, ) and metagenomic data sets (Schmieder & Edwards, ). To address the problem of interspecific contamination, bioinformatic tools have been developed to remove exogenous DNA from sequence data (Schmieder & Edwards, ) before contaminated sequences are incorporated into downstream analyses.…”