Fair Labor Practices in Values-Based Agrifood Supply Chains?

Abstract

This research commentary reviews our exploratory study of the incorporation of fair labor practices into the business models of values-based agrifood supply chains (VBSCs) studied in the USDAsponsored "agriculture-of-the-middle" (AOTM) regional research project. We examined what the certification affiliations of AOTM enterprises signaled about their values priorities as described in AOTM case study documents and in the enterprises' website advertising outreach. While we found weak evidence for prioritization of the fair labor practices value in these case study materials, our analysis suggests that characteristics of VBSC lead enterprises-whether the VBSCs are producer-, consumer-, or aggregator-drivenprovide a promising focus for future research into possibilities for fair labor practices in these types of alternative agrifood enterprises. In an effort to advance research on this important but relatively neglected topic in the alternative agriculture literature, we note the need to develop effective, ethical research strategies to investigate sensitive labor issues in alternative agrifoood supply chains and to identify labor-intensive VBSCs as future case study targets.

Untitled

“…In our concluding discussion, we suggest that a food systems framework would alleviate some of the disjunction in such perspectives (see Burmeister & Tanaka, 2017). Seeing farmers, intermediaries, and workers as part of a larger food system, rather than as opposing actors, helps to address disjointed and politicized narratives regarding farm labor reforms.…”

“…Yet a more regional and systems-based definition of food security, as suggested by food systems scholars, contrasts with this understanding. A broader understanding of food security-one focused on protecting moderate-sized farms' viability and preventing further concentration of the agricultural sector-provides opportunities for more just food systems to emerge (Burmeister & Tanaka, 2017;Clapp, 2021;Friesner, 2016;Hauter, 2012;Smaje, 2020).…”

National food security, immigration reform, and the importance of worker engagement in agricultural guestworker debates

“…Yet a more regional and systems-based definition of food security, as suggested by food systems scholars, contrasts with this understanding. A broader understanding of food security-one focused on protecting moderate-sized farms' viability and preventing further concentration of the agricultural sector-provides opportunities for more just food systems to emerge (Burmeister & Tanaka, 2017;Clapp, 2021;Friesner, 2016;Hauter, 2012;Huber, 2020;Smaje, 2020).…”

Between the farm and the fork: job quality in sustainable food systems

“…However, a dearth of data limits our understanding of AFS job quality and its role in AFS development. Those working between the farm and the fork, in occupations such as food production, sales, logistics, and food service, are rarely studied (Burmeister and Tanaka 2017 ). Some scholars have argued that a lack of national data on small farm labor, as opposed to small farm owners, has intentionally hidden inequitable labor practices on small farms (Moskowitz 2014 ; Arcury and Quandt 2009 ).…”