Factors Influencing the Reliability of the Universal Goniometer in Measurement of Lower-Limb Range of Motion

Abstract

Introduction: The universal goniometer (UG) is commonly used in clinical practice to measure lower limb joint range of motion (ROM). Reliability of the UG is essential to ensure consistency of measurement between and within practitioners. Clinically, it is important to understand how reliability may be affected by various factors. Methods: An electronic and manual literature search was conducted to determine the reliability of the UG. A variety of search terms were used to search between 1980 and July 2015. Papers sourced were graded according to the Scottish Intercollegiate Guideline Network guidelines. Papers reviewed included both measurements of healthy subjects and those with different pathologies. Active and passive lower limb ROM were studied and intratester and intertester reliability were examined. Results: Twenty one studies were included and fully reviewed. Most studies indicated that UG reliability was best when used to measure ROM in healthy subjects in comparison to patients. The limited number of studies measuring active motion compromised the ability to make comparisons with measuring of passive ROM. It was reported from the studies investigating both intratester and intertester reliability that intratester reliability was higher than intertester reliability. Reliability of measurements varied depending on the joint measured. Tester training and standardisation of the measurement procedure led to increased reliability and there was a suggestion that involving two testers in the measurement procedure may have a beneficial effect. Conclusion: This literature review highlights variation in study methodology employed, which reduces the ability to directly compare studies. Clinicians should be aware of the variability of 3 reliability of the UG and the effect of different factors when interpreting measurements taken with this instrument. Further research is required to investigate the effect different factors may have on the reliability of the UG and the possibility of using protocols and technology to increase reliability when measuring joint ROM.

Semi-Automating Low Back Compression Force Estimations with an Inertial Sensor

“…Universal standard goniometers have shown good validity and reliability but are prone to errors involving method standardisation and tester expertise [20]. There is currently no standard method of using a universal goniometer to measure the angles of the L5-S1 joints.…”

Validity and Intra-Rater Reliability of Laser Goniometer Versus Electro-Goniometer in Measuring Shoulder Range of Motion

“…This showed that the laser goniometer capable of providing high precision, accuracy, and consistency in measuring the involved movements repeatedly. The factor of long practical experience and training of the examiner and the good standardization each procedure of each measurement help to leading for these high-reliability correlation coefficient values [14].…”