Factors influencing perceptions of private water quality in North America: a systematic review

Abstract

Background An estimated four million and 43 million people in Canada and the USA use private water supplies. Private water supplies are vulnerable to waterborne disease outbreaks. Private water supplies in Canada and the USA are often unregulated and private water management is often a choice left to the owner. Perceptions of water quality become important in influencing the adoption of private water stewardship practices, therefore safeguarding public health. Methods We conducted a systematic literature review to understand factors that shape perceptions of water quality among private water users. We searched six computer databases (Web of science, Medline, Scopus, EBSCO, PubMed and Agricola). The search was limited to primary peer-reviewed publications, grey literature and excluded conference proceedings, review articles, and non-peer review articles. We restricted the search to papers published in English and to articles which published data on surveys of private water users within Canada and the USA. The search was also restricted to publications from 1986 to 2017. The literature search generated 36,478 records. Two hundred and four full text were reviewed. Results Fifty-two articles were included in the final review. Several factors were found to influence perceptions of water quality including organoleptic preferences, chemical and microbiological contaminants, perceived risks, water well infrastructure, past experience with water quality, external information, demographics, in addition to the values, attitudes, and beliefs held by well owners. Conclusions Understanding the factors that shape perceptions of water quality among private water users is an important step in developing private water management policies to increase compliance towards water testing and treatment in Canada and the USA. As many jurisdictions in Canada and the USA do not have mandatory private water testing or treatment guidelines, delineating these factors is an important step in informing future research and guiding policy on the public health of private water systems. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1186/s13643-019-1013-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Risk Communication and Factors Influencing Private Well Testing Behavior: A Systematic Scoping Review

“…For instance, many well owners were confident in their water quality, despite infrequent testing and invalidly relying on their sensory perceptions to detect contamination. A recent review of factors influencing perceptions of private well water quality in North America identified well water quality perceptions as an important consideration in well water testing behavior, upholding this aspect of our findings [49]. Individuals appear to be more motivated to test their own well if they learn that a neighbor has tested than if they learn that wells in their town/vicinity are actually contaminated.…”

Water Quality from the Sources of Non-Centralized Water Supply within the Rural Settlements of Zhytomyr Region

“…Based on the above, the responsibility for ensuring water safety in the sources of non-centralized water supply is still with individual households. This statement is also reflected in the work of Zheng, Flanagan (2017), Hooks et al (2019), and Munene, Hall (2019).…”

Drinking Water Consumption Patterns among Private Well Users in Ontario: Implications for Exposure Assessment of Waterborne Infection

“…Several Canadian studies have noted that while the majority of well users are able to identify environmental risks associated with contamination events in private wells (e.g., proximity to livestock and septic tanks, flooding, etc. ), their perception of water quality in response to these risks are indirectly mediated by changes to organoleptic properties and not necessarily the physical presentation of symptomatic infection (Malecki, Schultz, Severtson, Anderson, & VanDerslice, 2017; Munene & Hall, 2019; Roche, Jones‐Bitton, Majowicz, Pintar, & Allison, 2013). Thus, well users do not seem to accurately perceive risk in drinking the well water and will continue to be exposed and risk possible infection from waterborne pathogens.…”