Factors influencing adherence to regular exercise in middle-aged women: a qualitative study to inform clinical practice

Abstract

BackgroundAbout half of women decrease their regular exercise during middle age. Concurrently, they experience a reduction in basal metabolic rate and loss of lean muscle as they transition to menopause. The combined effects place these women at increased risk for body weight gain and associated co-morbidities. Further research is required to better assess their barriers to regular exercise and to develop more applied knowledge aimed to improve the applicability of clinical interventions aimed at this population. The main aim of this study was to identify enablers and barriers influencing adherence to regular exercise in middle-aged women who exercise.MethodsAn interpretive description qualitative study was conducted using individual interviews. The two key questions were focused on planning to engage in physical activity and succeeding or planning to engage in physical activity and not succeeding. Inductive content analysis was used.ResultsFifty-three women interviewed were aged 40–62 years and experiencing mild to moderate menopausal symptoms. Six broad themes influencing adhering to regular exercise were: routine, intrinsic motivation, biophysical issues, psychosocial commitments, environmental factors, and resources. Common sub-themes were identified as enabling factors: daily structure that incorporated physical activity (broad theme routine), anticipated positive feelings associated with physical activity (intrinsic), and accountability to others (psychosocial). Other common sub-themes identified as barriers were disruptions in daily structure (routine), competing demands (routine) and self-sacrifice (psychosocial).ConclusionsThe most common barrier middle-aged women describe as interfering with adhering to regular exercise was attributable to the demands of this life stage at home and with others. Lack of time and menopausal symptoms were not identified as the common barriers. To support women to adhere to regular exercise, healthcare professionals should consider a narrative approach to assessing barriers and focus on enablers to overcoming identified barriers.

Levels of Physical Activity among Kuwaiti Adults and Perceived Barriers

“…These barriers were also stated as the most common barriers to physical activity in many other countries [2,29]. Females in our study had a higher percent of laziness, lack of time and fatigue which can be justified by their higher family responsibilities in comparison to men [20,29].…”

“…After review of literature [13,14,19,20], 19 barriers were selected and categorized into Personal barriers (12 items), Social barriers (4 items) and Environmental barriers (3 items). Participants could choose more than one item in every category and the percent of each barrier was calculated according to the number of participants who selected it.…”

The Effect of an Enhanced Rehabilitation Exercise Treatment of Non-Specific Low Back Pain- A suggestion for Rehabilitation Specialists

“…This recommends patients could be given a decision on which kind of activity program they would generally appreciate. This is imperative as the pleasure in practice is a critically consider practice adherence [68,124,125,126].…”

The Effects of Supervised Aerobic and Resistance Exercise Training on Sri Lankan Adults with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus - Sri Lanka Diabetes Aerobic and Resistance Training (SL-DART) Study

“…For example, a young person may be more body image conscious and want to reduce weight, while an elderly person may like to improve activities of daily living including improvement of balance and reduction of muscular discomfort and pain. Personal importance and relatedness will allow the individual to explore avenues to incorporate exercise into their lifestyle [236].…”

“…When the environment can be optimised along with the individual training prescription referenced in this paper, more long-lasting changes can be achieved [236].…”