Factors Associated with Satisfaction of Hospital Physicians: A Systematic Review on European Data

Abstract

Background: Physician satisfaction is a multidimensional concept related to many factors. Despite the wide range of research regarding factors affecting physician satisfaction in different European countries, there is a lack of literature reviews analyzing and summarizing current evidence. The aim of the article is to synthetize the literature studying the factors associated with physician satisfaction. Methods: We searched: MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO, CINAHL and the Cochrane Library from January 2000 to January 2017. The eligibility criteria included: (1) target population: physicians working in European hospitals; (2) quantitative research aimed at assessing physician satisfaction and associated factors; (3) use of validated tools. We performed a narrative synthesis. Results: After screening 8585 records, 368 full text articles were independently checked and finally 24 studies were included for qualitative analysis. The included studies surveyed 20,000 doctors from 12 European countries. The tools and scales used in the analyzed research to measure physician satisfaction varied to a large extent. We extracted all pre-specified factors, reported as statistically significant/non-significant. Analyzed factors were divided into three groups: personal, intrinsic and contextual factors. The majority of factors are modifiable and positively associated with characteristics of contextual factors, such as work-place setting/work environment. In the group of work-place related factors, quality of management/leadership, opportunity for professional development and colleague support have been deemed statistically significant in numerous studies. Conclusions: We identified more studies appraising the effect of contextual factors (such as work environment, work-place characteristics), highlighting a positive association between those factors and physician satisfaction, compared with personal and intrinsic factors. Numerous studies confirmed statistically significant associations between physician satisfaction and quality of management, professional development and colleague support/team climate. Due to the health workforce crisis, knowledge regarding physician satisfaction and associated factors is essential to healthcare managers and policy makers for more stable human resources management.

Understanding the professional satisfaction of hospital trainees in Australia

“…However, in a separate analysis we found that those making >AU$150 000 per year were significantly less satisfied than those in the median income group, which indicates that there may be a ceiling effect to income and satisfaction. There is very little other evidence in this area for specialist trainees although a large 2002 study carried out in UK hospital physicians found that only the middle‐income band (GBP35 000‐49 999) reported significantly higher levels of satisfaction in comparison with the lowest (GBP20 000) and otherwise found no clear effect of income . By contrast, in general practice, the link between low remuneration and poor job satisfaction has been well established in studies from a multiplicity of countries and settings, with most of these studies emphasising dissatisfaction when there is a discrepancy between long hours and remuneration .…”

Exploring Satisfaction and Migration Intentions of Physicians in Three University Hospitals in Poland

“…Researchers in numerous countries have conducted studies focused on satisfaction [4,8,9] as well as stress and burnout among physicians working in university hospitals [10][11][12]. Physician satisfaction is a complex and multidimensional concept which can be affected by personal and external factors [13,14]. Physicians' satisfaction has significant effects on their productivity, their work ability, and the quality of patient care, as well as their intentions to leave the job or their intent to continue practicing medicine [15][16][17].In 2018 in Poland, there were 36 university hospitals owned and operated by 13 public medical universities.…”

A Multidimensional Questionnaire to Measure Career Satisfaction of Physicians: Validation of the Polish Version of the 4CornerSAT

“…A lack of validated and reliable psychometric instruments limit study results, as well as their comparability [32]. Also, researchers call for international collaborative studies to better understand the satisfaction of physicians and associated factors [2,33]. Similarly, multifaceted measures of physicians' satisfaction are needed to understand challenges and define effective actions to improve the wellness of physicians [2].…”