Factors affecting communication in emergency departments: doctors and nurses’ perceptions of communication in a trilingual ED in Hong Kong

Abstract

BackgroundThis study investigates clinicians’ views of clinician-patient and clinician-clinician communication, including key factors that prevent clinicians from achieving successful communication in a large, high-pressured trilingual Emergency Department (ED) in Hong Kong.MethodsResearchers interviewed 28 doctors and nurses in the ED. The research employed a qualitative ethnographic approach. The interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed, translated into English and coded using the Nvivo software. The researchers examined issues in both clinician-patient and clinician-clinician communication. Through thematic analyses, they identified the factors that impede communication most significantly, as well as the relationship between these factors. This research highlights the significant communication issues and patterns in Hong Kong EDs.ResultsThe clinician interviews revealed that communication in EDs is complex, nuanced and fragile. The data revealed three types of communication issues: (1) the experiential parameter (i.e. processes and procedures), (2) the interpersonal parameter (i.e. clinicians’ engagements with patients and other clinicians) and (3) contextual factors (i.e. time pressures, etc.). Within each of these areas, the specific problems were the following: compromises in knowledge transfer at key points of transition (e.g. triage, handover), inconsistencies in medical record keeping, serious pressures on clinicians (e.g. poor clinician-patient ratio and long working hours for clinicians) and a lack of focus on interpersonal skills.ConclusionsThese communication problems (experiential, interpersonal and contextual) are intertwined, creating a complex yet weak communication structure that compromises patient safety, as well as patient and clinician satisfaction. The researchers argue that hospitals should develop and implement best-practice policies and educational programmes for clinicians that focus on the following: (1) understanding the primary causes of communication problems in EDs, (2) accepting the tenets and practices of patient-centred care, (3) establishing clear and consistent knowledge transfer procedures and (4) lowering the patient-to-clinician ratio in order to create the conditions that foster successful communication. The research provides a model for future research on the relationship between communication and the quality and safety of the patient safety.

The relationship between professional communication competences and nursing performance of critical care nurses in South Korea

“…This present study reports that both the communication competences and nursing performance of ICU staff nurses were at a fairly confident level compared with previous studies (Adams et al, ; Aslakson et al, ; Bry et al, ). Confident communication and nursing performance can be influenced by a number of factors such as cultural variables, beliefs concerning the importance of communication, and the socio‐economic background and work environment such as nurse‐to‐patient ratio, work shift, and advanced technologies and equipment in health care settings (Kounenou et al, ; Pun, Matthiessen, Murray, & Slade, ). Thus, future studies should consider multidimensional aspects and factors that influence the communication competences and clinical performance of critical care nurses.…”

Complexities of emergency communication: clinicians’ perceptions of communication challenges in a trilingual emergency department

“…These factors create a complicated process of multilingual communication that may be time‐intensive, difficult to document and susceptible to errors (Pun et al . ). In addition to issues associated with constant translation in a multilingual healthcare context, clinicians in Hong Kong EDs face high levels of stress due to high patient loads, limited time per patient and a lack of integration between different medical services (Tam & Lau ).…”

Nurses’ perceptions of mandatory bedside clinical handovers: An Australian hospital study

“…Yet the rapid pace and increasing complexity of twenty‐first century hospital care, coupled with high patient loads, make it difficult for clinicians to communicate effectively and consistently with colleagues and patients. Recent research shows that the pressure on clinicians is greater than ever (Eggins & Slade, ; Pun, Matthiessen, Slade, & Murray, ; Slade et al, ). Additional studies have shown that some doctors and nurses, particularly junior staff, are likely to remain silent in the face of perceived patient risk, even if a standardized health care communication tool is in place (Schwappach & Gehring, ).…”