Facebook’s “Free Basics”: For or against community development?

Abstract

A recent discussion on a prominent community informatics (CI) listserv revealed arguments for and against the Facebook’s Free Basics platform among researchers in the field. To continue and enrich the conversation, this study first examines the contrasting stances revealed in the CI listserv discussion and derives the CI researchers’ major concerns about the platform. Under the light of these concerns, we then explore the nature of Facebook’s Free Basics in relation to community development through analysis of one of the forefront services that Free Basics offers, i.e., Facebook. Specifically, we examine relationships between uses of Facebook and information technology (IT) identity formation and social capital. We argue that although projects operated by private companies may possess potential for supporting community development, much consideration is needed in embracing the technology solutions due to the risks and restrictions they can impose on its users. We also suggest the CI researchers to open the next round of discussion regarding ways to thoroughly assess possible flaws of Free Basics and help users of the platform make more informed decisions. IT identity is a new theory that can help shed new light on the challenges of using platforms such as Free Basics and their contribution to community development.

Teaching “Against” Social Media: Confronting Problems of Profit in the Curriculum

“…In the United States, more Americans find news via social media than via newspapers (Shearer, 2018); 90% of teens use social media, and almost half claim to be "almost constantly" online (Jiang, 2018); and more than two thirds (68%) of adults use Facebook, with almost three quarters (74%) of those users visiting the site at least once a day (Gramlich, 2018). By not charging for data through their Free Basics initiative, Facebook provides the primary access to the Internet for many citizens in more than 40 countries (Yim, Gomez, & Carter, 2016). Educators have responded disparately to this seismic media shift.…”

An Analysis on the Responses of Major US-based International Companies to External Pressures—On the Example of Apple and Facebook

“…Facebook promoted the "Free Basics" program in India in 2014 which allows the Indians to access some websites without cost. The program is carried out by two Indian firms but banned by the government in 2016 [22] . The reason is some people think it might be against the net neutrality policy, and it is a discriminatory pricing.…”