Extreme wet conditions coincident with Bronze Age abandonment of upland areas in Britain

Abstract

Abandonment of farming systems on upland areas in southwest Britain during the Late Bronze Age -some 3000 years ago -is widely considered a 'classic' demonstration of the impact of deteriorating climate on the vulnerability of populations in such marginal environments. Here we test the hypothesis that climate change drove the abandonment of upland areas by developing new chronologies for human activity on upland areas during the Bronze Age across southwest Britain (Dartmoor, Exmoor and Bodmin Moor). We find Bronze Age activity in these areas spanned 3900 to 2950 calendar years ago with abandonment by 2900 calendar years ago. Holocene Irish bog and lake oak tree populations provide evidence of major shifts in hydroclimate across the British Isles, coincident with ice rafted debris layers recognized in North Atlantic marine sediments, indicating significant changes in the latitude and intensity of zonal atmospheric circulation across the region. We observe abandonment of upland areas in southwest Britain coinciding with a sustained period of extreme wet conditions that commenced 3100 calendar years ago. Our results are consistent with the view that climate change increased the vulnerability of these early farming communities and led to a less intensive use of such marginal environments across Britain.

Evolution and extinction of the giant rhinoceros Elasmotherium sibiricum sheds light on late Quaternary megafaunal extinctions

“…Modelled ages are reported here at the 95% probability range in thousands of calendar years BP (cal ka BP; relative to AD 1950). This method has been applied to a wide range of contexts including studies on megafaunal and Neanderthal extinction 35,65 , archaeological phases of occupation and ceramic development 66,67 , and palaeoearthquakes 68 , providing robust age estimates for the start and end of phases, often with fewer 14 C measurements than those reported here. In OxCal, commands or parameters are written in a CQL (Command Query Language).…”

Was There a 3.2 ka Crisis in Europe? A Critical Comparison of Climatic, Environmental, and Archaeological Evidence for Radical Change during the Bronze Age–Iron Age Transition

“…In both islands, settlements occupied most environmental niches in the landscape, ranging from the fertile plains of southern England to rugged Atlantic islands off the coast of Ireland. Some may have been more exposed to climatic change impacts than others, for example, the upland settlements of southwest England (Turney et al 2016).…”

Long-term human impact and environmental change in mid-western Ireland, with particular reference to Céide Fields – an overview

“…10; especially the tree-ring (both pine and oak) records from Ireland and Ger-many), it is difficult to justify invoking climate change as the main factor determining levels of farming activity in the north Mayo region and indeed Ireland generally (cf. Krossa et al, 2017;Stevens and Fuller, 2015;Stolze et al, 2013;Turney et al, 2006Turney et al, , 2016; for a general discussion on determinism in archaeological contexts see Arponen et al, 2019a). Rather it would appear that farming and human population dynamics were more influenced by factors such as cultural developments and societal changes (cf.…”