Exploring trade‐offs between staffing levels and turnaround time in a pathology laboratory using discrete event simulation

Abstract

Summary Many health delivery services have required performance targets. Typically, these targets are presented as percentiles of patients to be seen within specified timeframes. These targets present hospital administrators with a resourcing problem complicated by conflicting objectives: How to minimize costs while maximizing throughput to achieve the performance targets? In this paper, we describe the use of a simulation model to evaluate the effect of changes to staff levels in a cytology department, investigating the trade‐off between staff levels and turnaround times in light of performance targets specified by government. Standard practice for determining staffing levels in a cytology department uses average workload estimates and does not take into account target performance measures, task variability, and the interruptive nature of the workload of pathologists. We develop a simulation model for pathologist workload within a cytology department in New Zealand. We describe the model construction process that follows the hierarchical control conceptual modeling (HCCM) framework. We use the resulting simulation model to examine the trade‐offs between staffing levels (and associated rosters) and task turnaround time. The results indicate that consideration of variation in task arrivals is important when considering the effect of staffing levels on turnaround time. Furthermore, as the cytology department is required to meet performance targets that involve maximum service times for a percentile of patients, such an approach is necessary in order to estimate the performance level of a staffing roster.

A discrete event simulation for improving operating theatre efficiency

“…In the last 2 decades there has been an explosive increase in the number of DES publications and a claimed diffusion of DES into healthcare 8 . It has been observed that the applications of DES are largely confined to specific health care units, with modelling of emergency departments the most popular setting 9,10 and many applications seeking to improve time‐ and efficiency‐related metrics 9,11 and cost‐effectiveness 12 . A recent systematic review found an increasing trend towards using DES in healthcare to address issues at an operational level, yet less than 10% of DES applications presented actual implementations following the modelling stage 9 .…”

Lean healthcare integrated with discrete event simulation and design of experiments: an emergency department expansion

“…Regarding planning and capacity analysis, (Pinto et al 2015) defined the ideal number of beds for a Brazilian hospital. For the balancing of staff work (Reynolds et al 2011) applied the simulation to reduce the workload of an English pharmacy and (Pongjetanapong et al 2019) used the tool to evaluate the effect of changes to staff levels in a cytology department.…”

A Simulation Study on Demand Disruptions and Limited Resources for Healthcare Provision

“…Authors revealed a growing interest on the use of Discrete Event Simulation (DES) as a performance analysis tool in 81% out of 254 selected papers. Recent studies have applied DES to situations where resource management scenarios exploration was essential to reduce operational costs and increase performance [2,14].…”