Exploring the influence of individual and academic differences on the placement participation rate among international students

Abstract

This cover sheet may not be removed from the document.Please scroll down to view the document. | P a g eExploring the influence of individual and academic differences on the placement participation rate among international students: A UK case study Abstract Purpose: The paper investigates the low placement participation rate among international students compared with UK students, by examining the impact of individual factors such as gender and domicile and academic achievement such as prior academic qualification, prior academic results and subsequent academic results on students' choices of degree programmes as well as their graduation status. Methodology:This study adopts a quantitative approach by using 268 accounting and finance students in a UK university. Findings:The analyses show that UK students on entry are 35% more likely than international students to choose a degree programme with a placement module after controlling for individual and academic differences. Among females, international students who switch to a degree without placement following entry significantly and statistically underperformed their UK counterparts who complete a degree with placement from the first year onwards. This trend is not observable among male students. Instead, male students who select and graduate with a degree without placement are the worst performers, regardless of their nationalities. Research limitation:The quantitative data used here are collected in a UK institution so the results reported here may lack generalisability. Practical implications:International students need to know more about the benefits of undertaking placements on their academic performance and the development of generic skills before entry. Moreover, UK universities need to provide more assistance to international students, especially females about how to secure placements and how to widen their search for potential placements. | P a g eOriginality/value: To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to explain the low participation rate among international students in UK higher education.Keywords: Placements; international students; academic performance; self-selection; accounting and finance students IntroductionAccording to the OECD report (2014), the United Kingdom was one of the top three most popular destinations for international students. This has made UK higher education an important arena in which to understand how international students develop and settle in English speaking settings. The increasing presence of international students in UK higher education raises a pedagogic question of whether the UK higher educational system is designed to afford all students the opportunity to participate in an educational offering such as placements, regardless of individual and academic differences. Placements require students to undertake a period of work experience during their degree study period (Little and Harvey , 2006) and can improve their chances of obtaining good degrees (2.1 or above) and/or better academic results in the fi...

Work integrated learning internships in transnational education

“…Australian higher education policy dictates that universities must provide employability-related outcomes relevant to international and transnational student contexts (Government of Australia, 2015) and support their skill development (Gamble et al, 2010). In the UK, Crawford et al (2016) recommended that universities provide international students with greater placement-related support. Given recognition for WIL internships as crucial vehicles for skill development, along with TNE's mandated role to produce employable graduates (Lee, 2017) it follows that universities are obligated to offer equivalent authentic WIL opportunities to transnational campus students as those based at the university's home campus (Wilkins and Huisman, 2013).…”

Higher achievers? Mobility programmes, generic skills, and academic learning: a UK case study

“…To examine the effects of yearlong study abroad on academic learning of the IMML students, this study uses quantitative data collected by the university. The quantitative approach is borrowed from the placement literature which examines student academic learning through placements by analysing the differences in academic results before and following placements while controlling for gender, age and domicile Crawford, Wang, & Andrews, 2016;Gomez, Lush, & Clements, 2004;Jones, Green, & Higson, 2015;Mandilaras, 2004;Mansfield, 2011;Surridge, 2009). The quantitative approach complements the study abroad literature in three ways.…”

Social mobility via elite placements: working class graduates in elite accounting and banking firms

“…First, what is the most important capital in the yearlong placement field where most students do not possess cultural capital valued by elite firms? Prior studies focusing on the yearlong placement field regardless of payment and the status of destination organisations find that high first and/second year averages are the only important factor in determining whether a student can secure a placement or not after controlling for prior entry academic differences and/or other factors such as age, gender or ethnicity (Crawford & Wang, 2015Crawford, Wang, & Andrews, 2016;Duignan, 2003;Gomez, Lush, & Clements, 2004;Jones, Green, & Higson, 2015;Mansfield, 2011;Reddy & Moores, 2006Surridge, 2009).…”