Exploring the Design and Use of Molecular Animations that Conflict for Understanding Chemical Reactions

Abstract

publicado na web em 05/04/2017Understanding chemical reactions conceptually involves recognizing characteristics of observable phenomena and envisioning how atoms, ions and molecules move and interact to cause the macroscopic changes. Our research focuses on the development of effective strategies for designing and presenting visualizations (videos and animations) to assist students with making connections between macroscopic and molecular level behaviors of chemical reactions. Specifically, we study how students, who view videos of a redox reaction that exhibits obvious signs of macroscopic chemical change, can determine which molecular animation of a set of contrasting animations is best supported by its fit with experimental evidence. Herein we describe how we develop our videos and animations, and how students are learning from this animation task. Students who select inaccurate animation models are often enticed by a model that is easier to explain and fits with their understanding of reaction equations. We note that even though students indicate a preference for one animation over another, they often revise their drawn representations to fit with features from multiple animations. With the assistance of eye tracking research, we are gaining a better understanding of what students view and how they make sense of it.

Students’ Procedure When Solving Problem Tasks Based on the Periodic Table: An Eye-Tracking Study

“…Attention has also been paid to various areas of chemical education research. Researchers studied, e.g., models, spectra reading, , or chemical reactions. ,, Research in these disciplines for example showed successful solvers (respectively experts) focus more on relevant information, ,, although there were some studies where the result was not proven. , This is possibly connected to their knowledge in this area . The results then translate to the time the students need to solve a task (faster than unsuccessful solvers , ).…”

Augmented Reality-based Media on Molecular Hybridization Concepts Learning

“…Students can understand chemistry conceptually if they can translate chemical phenomena into macroscopic, submicroscopic, and symbolic representations (Helsy & Andriyani, 2017;Safitri, Nursa'adah, & Wijayanti, 2019). Submicroscopic visualization is very important, so students understand the concept of chemistry as a whole (Kelly & Hansen, 2017). One concept that requires submicroscopic visualization is hybridization.…”

Decoding Case Comparisons in Organic Chemistry: Eye-Tracking Students’ Visual Behavior

“…Current eye-tracking research often compares visual behavior over different stages of expertise. Numerous studies in various fields show that with increasing expertise less time is taken, more fixations are made on relevant aspects of the display to successfully solve a specific task, and overall more “focused” behavior is shown. − In the context of chemistry, several studies apply eye-tracking in cases of multiple representations, such as text-image combinations, animations, or comparisons of different representational forms. − As for expertise comparisons in chemistry education research, successful students are also faster with a task and spend more time on relevant features of a representation. − Consequently, unsuccessful students distribute their attention more equally over areas of interest (AOI) containing different forms of representations. , Further, Tang and Pienta found that students who are unsuccessful at solving a gas law problem have more fixations on the question text than on the graphs that provide the essential information . In a study by Cullipher and Sevian, where students were supposed to explain how molecular structures cause specific spectra, successful students show more transitions between the different representations .…”