Exploring Chronically Ill Seniors' Attitudes About Discussing Death and Postmortem Medical Procedures

Abstract

Proxy decisions about postmortem medical procedures must consider the dead patient's likely preferences. Ethnic- and sex-based attitudes surely underlie such preferences but lack sufficient characterization to guide decisions. Therefore, this exploratory study interviewed Mexican-American, Euroamerican, and African-American seniors in San Antonio, Texas, for their attitudes about discussing death before it occurs and about organ donation, autopsy, and practice on cadavers. A rigorous content analysis identified themes. Majority attitudes of an ethnic group or sex subgroup here may characterize the group generally. Attitudes about discussing death differed only by ethnic group. Mexican Americans and Euroamericans favored such discussions, but African Americans did not. Attitudes about the postmortem procedures differed by ethnic group and sex. Overall, Mexican Americans viewed the procedures most favorably; Euroamericans, less so; and African Americans, least so. Men and women differed further within ethnic groups. Mexican-American men and women split evenly over organ donation, the men expressed no majority preference about autopsies and the women agreed to them, and the men refused and the women agreed to practice on their cadavers. Euroamerican men expressed no majority preferences, but Euroamerican women agreed to organ donation, had no majority preference about autopsies, and refused practice on their cadavers. African-American men expressed no majority preferences, and African-American women expressed none about organ donation or autopsies but refused practice on their cadavers. If confirmed, these ethnic- and sex-based attitudes can help health professionals tailor postmortem care to individual patients' preferences.

Using the medical record to evaluate the quality of end-of-life care in the intensive care unit*

“…Research has shown that there may be significant cultural differences in the way individuals and families cope with dying and death. (43,44,45) Our study population was largely white (78%) which raises the question as to whether these results are generalizable to other populations. In addition, of eligible decedents for whom we had chart abstraction, our response rate with valid QODD responses was only 41.2%.…”

Surrogate Decision-Makers' Perspectives on Discussing Prognosis in the Face of Uncertainty

“…Our study did not include participants from two ethnic groups (Navajo Indians and Hmong individuals) in which there is a belief that discussing the possibility of death can cause harm to the patient (32,33). In general, because of the cultural variability in attitudes on discussing death, our findings should be applied only with great caution to these ethnic groups and others-including African Americansfor whom similar beliefs are common (34). We interviewed subjects at only one timepoint during a patient's ICU stay (between Days 3 and 5 of the patient receiving mechanical ventilation).…”

Cultural Beliefs About a Patient’s Right Time to Die: An Exploratory Study

“…We explored beliefs about dying among Mexican Americans (MAs), Euro-Americans (EAs), and African Americans (AAs) [27][28][29][30] as well as their gender subgroups. We considered gender …”