Expert and Diffuse Design of a Sustainable Circular Economy in Two German Circular Roadmap Projects

Abstract

According to sustainability transitions theory, socio-technical change requires a convergence of politics, social change, technology, and niche innovations. Recently, a circular economy has been proposed as the engine of such change in the EU New Green Deal and Germany. Mainstream circular economy emphasizes the closing of material loops as the way to ensure green growth, and there is a key role for design to achieve such change. According to reports, however, the global appetite for a circular economy remains limited and critics have pointed to several contradictions between the rhetoric and reality of the circular economy and sustainable development. In addition, current formulations of circular economy misrepresent the plurality of discourses for a sustainable circular economy and the role of expert and diffuse circular design. In this study, we employ the recently articulated ten principles for a sustainable circular economy and society to analyze two contrasting circular roadmap projects in Germany, which reflect two contrasting technical and reformist circular discourses, and understandings of the role of design. We find that there are narrow and broad interpretations of design inherent in these circular policies as well as the exemplification of the difference between a technical circular economy and reformist circular society discourses. The practical applied value of this analysis is that the framework can be employed to analyze other policies.

The Circular Economy Transition in Australia: Nuanced Circular Intermediary Accounts of Mainstream Green Growth Claims

“…Thus, there is a real danger that mainstream CE has disengaged from sustainable development [68][69][70] and follows the same rules and outcomes as the linear economy it purports to replace [71]. The absence of a social and ecological focus in mainstream CE has led not only to critique, but to the emergence of narratives of a sustainable Circular Economy and circular society [72][73][74][75] as a complement or contrast to the mainstream CE narrative [76,77].…”

Imagining Decent Work towards a Green Future in a Former Forest Village of the City of Istanbul

“…We draw on studies on local initiatives reverberating 'quiet activism' (Pottinger 2016) that "prompted public awareness", such as the case of a local movement that instigated growing an indigenous wheat variety in the Aegean region of Turkey (Nizam and Yenal 2020). Viewing citizen participation as an integral part of sustainable transitions towards a circular economy (Melles et al 2022;Velenturf and Purnell 2021), we underline the potential of such community projects to enhance place attachment and social wellbeing. The initiative under focus here, Community Fungi, can be seen as an example of the concept of "grounded knowledge" and participatory action research put forward by (Ashwood et al 2014).…”