Experimental Study on the Effect of Vortex Generator on the Aerodynamic Characteristics of NASA LS-0417 Airfoil

Abstract

Boundary layer flow structure developing on an airfoil surfaces strongly affects drag and lift forces acting on the body. Many studies have been done to reduce drag, such as introducing surface roughness on the airfoil surface, gas injection, attachment of vortex generators, or moving surface on the airfoil. Previous results showed that the attachment of vortex generators has potentially been able to control boundary layer separation compared to other controlling devices. This study is focused on the evaluation of the effect of vortex generator attachment on the NASA LS-0417 airfoil profile as this profile is commonly used in wind turbine blade application. The models of this experimental study are NASA LS-0417 profiles, with and without vortex generator. The chord length of the profile is 110 mm, while the span is 210 mm. Profile of the vortex generator is a symmetrical profile of NACA 0012 configured in counter rotating and attached on the upper surface of the main profile. The chord length of the vortex generator is 7 mm with two different values of the height (h): 1 mm and 2 mm. The experiment was conducted in an open loop wind tunnel with maximum attainable freestream velocity of approximately 19 m/s and the turbulence intensity at the tunnel centerline is approximately 0.8%. The wind tunnel cross section is octagonal of 30 cm x 30 cm and of 45 cm to 60 cm adjustable length. The study was performed at two different freestream velocities of 12 m/s and 17 m/s corresponding with Reynolds numbers (Re) of 0.83 x 105 and 1.18 x 105 based on the airfoil chord length and the freestream velocity. Angle of attact (α) was varied from 0o to 24o. Drag and lift were measured using a force balance with measurement uncertainty of approximately 0.77% and 2.47% at measured drag of 0.65N and at measured lift of 0.202N, respectively. A flow visualization study using oil flow method was conducted to obtain qualitaive picture of flow structure on the airfoil surface. Results of this study showed that attachment of the vortex generator on the NASA LS-0417 profile has not been able to improve the profile performance compared to that of unmodified profile. There, however, seems Reynolds number effect on the airfoil performance flow conditions performed in this study. At lager Re, there is an increase in CL/CD of approximately 36% at angle of attack (α) 6o. Next, based on the flow visualization results, attachment of the 2mm vortex generator on the airfoil NASA LS-0417 surface results in an advancement of boundary layer separation at the two Re’s conducted in this study. Finally, the 2mm vortex generator accelerates airfoil stall at approximately 16o, while the 1mm vortex generator is relatively no effect on the airfoil stall angle.

Aerodynamic performance enhancement of an Airfoil using trapezoidal vortex generators

“…The performance of VGs has also been found dependent on the flow Reynolds number; experiments on the aerodynamic performance of a VG equipped NASA LS-0417 airfoil have shown improvements only for high Reynolds numbers (Sutardi and Agung, 2015). Additionally, this study has reported that the VGs have accelerated stall, which is undesirable.…”

Passive Flow Control Application Using Single and Double Vortex Generator on S809 Wind Turbine Airfoil

“…But at a larger Reynolds number, C L /C D increased by approximately 36%. [37] Simpler (2D) geometry Between 1 m/s and 10 m/s Wind tunnel research Two different VG applications were investigated. The results show that VGs with counter-rotating types ensured better results compared to VGs with co-rotating configurations.…”