“…The top valence band of Tm-doped ZnO remained stationary, whereas the bottom conduction band moved to a lower energy region in comparison to pure ZnO, as seen in Figure 2(b) and 2(c). The calculated bandgap of Ag- and Cu-doped ZnO is 2.970 eV and 3.294 eV, respectively, which agrees with other experimental reports (Benrezgua et al , 2021; Mishra et al , 2022). From the previous theoretical works (Wan et al , 2009; Liu et al , 2020), the value of bandgap Ag-doped ZnO was 2.80 eV and Cu-doped ZnO was 3.25 eV due to different computer code, functional and U p values applied to Ag 4 d state and Cu 3 d state.…”