Evidence that a 1,2-dihydroxycyclohexadienide anion is
stabilized
by aromatic “negative hyperconjugation” is described.
It complements an earlier inference of “positive” hyperconjugative
aromaticity for the cyclohexadienyl cation. The anion is a reactive
intermediate in the dehydration of benzene cis-1,2-dihydrodiol
to phenol. Rate constants for 3-substituted benzene cis-dihydrodiols are correlated by σ– values
with ρ = 3.2. Solvent isotope effects for the reactions are k
H2O/k
D2O = 1.2–1.8. These measurements are consistent
with reaction via a carbanion intermediate or a concerted reaction
with a “carbanion-like” transition state. These and
other experimental results confirm that the reaction proceeds by a
stepwise mechanism, with a change in rate-determining step from proton
transfer to the loss of hydroxide ion from the intermediate. Hydrogen
isotope exchange accompanying dehydration of the parent benzene cis-1,2-dihydrodiol was not found, and thus, the proton
transfer step is subject to internal return. A rate constant of ∼1011 s–1, corresponding to rotational relaxation
of the aqueous solvent, is assigned to loss of hydroxide ion from
the intermediate. The rate constant for internal return therefore
falls in the range 1011–1012 s–1. From these limiting values and the measured rate constant for hydroxide-catalyzed
dehydration, a pK
a of 30.8 ± 0.5
was determined for formation of the anion. Although loss of hydroxide
ion is hugely exothermic, a concerted reaction is not enforced by
the instability of the intermediate. Stabilization by negative hyperconjugation
is proposed for 1,2-dihydroxycyclohexadienide and similar anions,
and this proposal is supported by additional experimental evidence
and by computational results, including evidence for a diatropic (“aromatic”)
ring current in 3,3-difluorocyclohexadienyl anion.