“…JWP ASSESSMENT: The 1996 collaboration of Hofmann et al [5] combined with the 2002 collaboration of Hofmann et al [6] are accepted as the first evidence for the synthesis of element with atomic number 112, being supported by subsequent measurements of Morita et al [16,18], and by assignment of decay properties of likely hassium intermediates [9,11,13] in the decay chain originating from 277 112. tion studies using multi-GeV protons incident on a U target clearly indicated the production path was irreproducible as previously stressed [1,3,4]. The latter refutations have been challenged by Brandt [18,25], a member of the Marinov collaboration, in which he rejects the negative results because the same exact experiment as conducted by Marinov was not followed.…”