Experiences of the gender climate in clinical training – a focus group study among Swedish medical students

Abstract

BackgroundResearch shows that medical education is characterized by unequal conditions for women and men, but there is a lack of qualitative studies investigating the social processes that enable and maintain gender inequalities that include both male and female students. In this focus group study, we therefore explored male as well as female medical students’ experiences of the gender climate – i.e., how beliefs, values, and norms about gender were communicated – during clinical training and how the students dealt with these experiences.MethodsFocus group interviews were conducted with 24 medical students (nine men) at Umeå University, Sweden. The interviews were structured around personal experiences in clinical training where the participants perceived that gender had mattered. Data were analysed using qualitative content analysis.ResultsThe students described gender-stereotyped expectations, discriminatory treatment, compliments, comments, and demeaning jargon. Female students gave more personal and varied examples than the men. The students’ ways of handling their experiences were marked by efforts to fit in, for example, by adapting their appearance and partaking in the prevailing jargon. They felt dependent on supervisors and staff, and due to fear of repercussions they kept silent and avoided unpleasant situations and people rather than challenging humiliating jargon or supervisors who were behaving badly.ConclusionsEveryday communication of gender beliefs combined with students’ adaptation to stereotyped expectations and discrimination came across as fundamental features through which unequal conditions for male and female students are reproduced and maintained in the clinic. Because they are in a dependent position, it is often difficult for students to challenge problematic gender attitudes. The main responsibility for improvements, therefore, lies with medical school leadership who need to provide students and supervisors with knowledge about gendered processes, discrimination, and sexism and to organize reflection groups about the gender climate in order to improve students’ opportunities to discuss their experiences, and hopefully find ways to protest and actively demand change.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12909-016-0803-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

To select or be selected – gendered experiences in clinical training affect medical students’ specialty preferences

“…Attitudes towards gender in the educational environment have important implications for medical students’ clinical experiences. Female students are more likely to encounter sexism such as gender related prejudice, gender discrimination, and sexual harassment, than are their male peers [ 16 , 26 , 27 ]. Learners’ ways of being and acting are contested or confirmed by gender-related expectations and evaluations from staff and supervisors, affecting how they interpret their role as future physicians [ 11 , 13 , 26 ].…”

Medical students’ self-reported gender discrimination and sexual harassment over time

“…There is strong evidence that discriminating behaviors lead to negative consequences for medical students and their professional future. [36]. In addition, even observations of other students being mistreated have a negative impact [37].…”

“…Total 103 (27) 49 (18) 152 (23) 195 (36) 134 (33) 329 35Clinical < 20 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (0) Supplementary Figure/table Legend Supplementary Table 1: The questions used in the study and selected from the questionnaire. Supplementary Table 2: The frequency, de ned as once or at least twice of different examples of selfreported gender discrimination and sexual harassments, was calculated.…”

Burn-out and mental health of minority medical students in Hungarian medical education.

“…University training has a vital role in the support of minority students, in the improvement of attitudes and competencies related to minorities, in the recognition and mitigation of implicit biases or everyday microaggressions (85,(103)(104)(105)(106)(107)(108)(109) to prepare medical students for the care of a population being diverse in many respects.…”