Experience of clinical supervisors of international medical graduates in an Australian district hospital

Abstract

Objective Herein we record the experience of clinical supervisors of international medical graduates (IMGs) working as junior staff in a district hospital by examining supervisor perspectives on IMG performance, the factors affecting their performance and the requirements of supervision under these circumstances. Methods The present study had an open-ended exploratory qualitative design. Thirteen 13 open-ended, in-depth interviews were undertaken with supervisors of IMGs employed in a public district hospital in Queensland, Australia. Results The supervisors reported that, although performance was an individual and variable characteristic, IMGs tended to perform less well than Australian graduates and required more intensive supervision. Factors that affected performance were motivation and experience, and specifically lack of familiarity with the Australian healthcare system, lack of recent of practice, education, language, communication and cultural factors. English language proficiency was regarded as crucial to performance. Conclusions The additional work required to supervise IMGs in order to enable them to perform at a satisfactory level and successfully integrate into the Australian healthcare system needs to be recognised and resourced. Assistance with attaining proficiency in English and with communication skills over and above the standard required to pass the International English Language Testing System examination should be seriously considered as a means of improving performance. What is known about the topic? To date, there is little research available about the experience of supervisors of IMGs in Australia. What does this paper add? The findings of the present study make an important contribution to the literature by examining the critical role clinical supervisors of IMGs have in helping IMGs adapt to the Australian healthcare system and ensuring that they are able to provide quality health care. It identifies current challenges and highlights areas in need of attention to ensure a strong healthcare system for Australia. What are the implications for practitioners? Supervisors of IMGs need recognition of the extra time and expertise required in their role if they are to be effectively supported in their endeavours to integrate IMGs into the Australian health workforce. More attention needs to be given to the development of English language proficiency of IMGs, including colloquial usage, and communication in medical practice.

Exploring reasons for differences in performance between UK and international medical graduates in the Membership of the Royal College of General Practitioners Applied Knowledge Test: a cognitive interview study

“…Cultural difficulties were also apparent in IMG participants particularly during the early stages of training where the challenges of adapting to a new culture, different style of teaching, often in a new language was apparent 18 22 39 40. IMG doctors may lack preparation for entering UK specialty training for general practice, compared with UKGs who have previously had 5 years undergraduate medical training and an additional 2 years foundation training in the UK, for example, in relation to learning about guidelines or adapting from a disease-centred to patient-centred model of care 22 39…”

Medical professionalism of foreign-born and foreign-trained physicians under close scrutiny: A qualitative study with stakeholders in Germany

“…Participants proposed various strategies to deal with deviations from PS. Other studies had a narrower focus and examined whether stakeholders could affirm the need for better support structures and what support schemes should look like [ 29 , 30 , 43 , 80 – 82 ]. Educational support programs for FB&FT physicians have also been developed, presented and critically discussed [ 83 ].…”

The experiences of foreign doctors in Saudi Arabia: A qualitative study of the challenges and retention motives

“…For example, some of FDs in the present study have reported initial difficulties in communicating with patients. Several studies have identified the miscommunication between the FDs and their patients as a causing factor for medical errors ( Henderson et al., 2017 ; Triscott et al., 2016 ). Rothwell et al.…”

“…International studies have shown that FDs are usually experiencing several challenges while working outside their countries. The most common challenges noticed in these studies were cultural differences ( Balasubramanian et al., 2016 ; Henderson et al., 2017 ; Kamimura et al., 2017 ; Klingler and Marckmann, 2016 ), communication and language barriers ( Hatzidimitriadou and Psoinos, 2014 ; Henderson et al., 2017 ; Klingler and Marckmann, 2016 ; Reardon et al., 2014 ), dealing with new health system framework ( Henderson et al., 2017 ; Klingler and Marckmann, 2016 ; Triscott et al., 2016 ), and discrimination at work places ( Funfe, 2016 ; Hatzidimitriadou and Psoinos, 2014 ; Triscott et al., 2016 ). Klingler and Marckmann (2016) argued that if these challenges are not properly addressed it could affect the physicians' job satisfaction, turnover rates and consequently the retention of this much-needed healthcare personnel.…”