Exit Survey of Senior Residents: Cost Conscious but Uninformed

Abstract

Background Cost awareness, to ensure physician stewardship of limited resources, is increasingly recognized as an important skill for physicians. The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education has made cost awareness part of systems-based practice, a core competency of resident education. However, little is known about resident cost awareness. Objective We sought to assess senior resident self-perceived cost awareness and cost knowledge. Methods In March 2014, we conducted a cross-sectional survey of all emergency medicine, internal medicine, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopaedic surgery pediatrics, and medicine-pediatrics residents in their final year at Yale-New Haven Hospital. The survey examined attitudes toward health care costs and residents' estimates of order prices. We considered resident price estimates to be accurate if they were between 50% and 200% of the Connecticut-specific Medicare price. Results We sent the survey to 84 residents and received 47 completed surveys (56% response rate). Although more than 95% (45 of 47) felt that containing costs is the responsibility of every clinician, and 49% (23 of 47) agreed that cost influenced their decision when ordering, only 4% (2 of 47) agreed that they knew the cost of tests being ordered. No residents accurately estimated the price of a complete blood count with differential, and only 2.1% (1 of 47) were accurate for a basic metabolic panel. The overall accuracy of all resident responses was 25%. Conclusions In our study, many trainees exit residency with self-identified deficiencies in knowledge about costs. The findings show the need for educational approaches to improve cost awareness among trainees.

Choosing Wisely in Pediatric Internship

“…These results indicate that residents are aware of the limitations of knowledge about procedural costs and, if better informed, would modify the number of requests for tests that would not add value to patient care. 35…”

Impact of Cost Display on Ordering Patterns for Hospital Laboratory and Imaging Services

“…INTERVENTION: Display of order costs, based on Medicare fee schedules, in the EHR for 1032 lab tests and 1329 imaging tests. MAIN MEASURES: Outcomes for both lab and imaging orders were (1) whether an order was placed during a hospital encounter, (2) whether an order was placed on a given patient-day, (3) number of orders placed per patientday, and (4) cost of orders placed per patient-day. KEY RESULTS: During the lab and imaging study periods, there were 248,214 and 258,267 encounters, respectively.…”

“…Physicians remain largely unaware of the costs of tests and therapies they order and find cost information inaccessible. 1,2 Nevertheless, physicians desire cost information and believe it would change their ordering without negatively affecting patient care 3,4 by prompting them to forego ordering low-value tests or to switch orders to less costly alternatives of equal clinical utility.…”

Can a simple ‘cost-awareness’ campaign for laparoscopic hysterectomy change the use and costs of disposable surgical supplies? Pre–post non-controlled study

“…This role has even been incorporated into physician training,4 and physicians are encouraged to be aware of the costs of treatment options so that they can provide cost-effective and safe treatments 2. Despite these expectations, awareness of healthcare costs is poor in a variety of surgical disciplines including gynaecology,5–7 with physicians consistently underestimating the cost of more expensive items 8–10…”