“…In a particularly promising finding, Hu and co-workers used vanadium-doped mesoporous amorphous silica photocatalysts (VO 4 /MCM-41), which was demonstrated to give high methanol selectivity (88.4%) . The structure and mechanism by which vanadium-doped mesoporous amorphous silica photocatalysts function has been somewhat contested, focusing mainly on whether the VO 4 group is bound to the surface of mesoporous material, or whether it is incorporated into the amorphous framework. , Additionally, the nature of the catalytic photoactive site as well as its formation has been analyzed both experimentally and theoretically, revealing that photon absorption oxidizes the terminal oxygen site and reduces the vanadium center, before undergoing intersystem crossing (ISC) to yield the reactive center. , However, to date the mechanism of the photocatalytic cycle has not been enumerated or validated. In particular, it is unclear whether the reaction proceeds by a radical mechanism, in which only the VO 4 site is involved and the amorphous silica acts as a support, or if the amorphous silica plays an important role in modifying activation barriers to control the selectivity.…”