Exchange Rates and the Choice of Ownership Structure of Production Facilities

Abstract

The aim of this research is to study the effects of real exchange rates on the long-term ownership strategies of production facilities of firms entering foreign markets. Among the strategies considered are exporting (EXP), joint ventures with local partners (JV), and wholly owned production facilities (WOS) in the foreign country. Our research takes a first step in modeling the influence of exchange rates on the choice and dynamic adjustment of such strategies. The insights obtained from our modeling analysis are then translated into testable hypotheses and empirically verified with the use of firm level data from U.S. multinational corporations (both at the firm and a more aggregate level). An insightful result of our model is the identification of a hysteresis phenomenon that characterizes switching behavior between strategies in the presence of switchover cost. The magnitude of the hysteresis band, which is a measure of the inertia associated with keeping the current ownership structure, is affected by a multiplicity of factors such as exchange rate volatility and market power of the entering firm. Analytical and numerical results on the effects of such factors on the hysteresis band are provided. The four testable hypotheses generated from our modeling analysis are rigorously tested with the use of a multinomial logit model on data obtained from the Harvard Multinational Enterprise database, and a data set maintained by the Bureau of Economic Analysis, the U.S. Department of Commerce. The empirical results strongly support our insights that relatively depreciated real exchange rates (i.e., weak home currency) favor (a) the JV over the WOS and (b) EXP mode over the WOS or JV. Finally, we summarize our results into useful guidelines for global production managers.Production Strategy, International Business, Ownership Structure, Exporting, Joint Ventures, Global Pricing Policy, Hysterisis, Real Options, Exchange Rates, Dynamic Programming

Global supply chain design: A literature review and critique

“…Specifically, the company entities included in the supply network are selected to minimize the performance range under all exchange rate scenarios and so provides a robust solution. This research was extended in Kouvelis et al (2001) to investigate ownership structure and the exchange rate conditions under which exporting, joint ventures, or wholly owned production facilities are appropriate.…”

On the growth of foreign affiliates: multinational plant networks, joint ventures, and flexibility

“…Buckley and Casson (1979) stress that market size, as related to the presence of scale economies, is crucial in foreign investment decisions. The product cycle theory of Vernon (1979) 6 The value of joint ventures as growth options has been studied in the context of downward risk implications (Reuer and Leiblein, 2000), and MNEs' entry mode choice in response to uncertainty in real exchange rate movements (Kouvelis et al, 2001) and market uncertainty (Chi and McGuire, 1996). Recent studies have further explored the application of the real options approach to IJVs and suggest that type of uncertainty (exogenous vs. endogenous to the venture) is an important moderator of the impact of the option value of joint ventures on MNE's entry mode decisions (Li and Rugman, 2005;Cuypers and Martin, 2006).…”

Vertical Flexibility, Outsourcing and the Financial Choices of the Firm

“…If such an interaction did not exist, the value of the firm would be the sum of debt and equity and the use of debt would not erode the value of equity, i.e., V L (c t ; α) = V U (c t ; α). 23 …”