Examining virtual reality as a platform for developing mental models of industrial systems

Abstract

Industrial systems can be complex and not intuitive to perceive. Therefore, students in technology and engineering programs can benefit from developing mental models of industrial systems during their journey in college. However, more often than not, these students do not have access to industrial facilities; thus, developing mental models for systems is a challenge. This paper examines the merit of an Immersive Virtual Reality (IVR) framework application in creating proper mental models for industrial systems in technology and engineering students. Two IVR applications were developed. One IVR application afforded interaction with components of a prefabricated industrial cooling water system (CWVR). In the other application, students designed and built industrial systems with IVR (system designer VR [SDVR]). SDVR facilitated constructivegenerative engagement. A group of 33 students was divided into two; one group (the Design, experimental group) was tasked with building a system with SDVR and interacting with the cooling water system in CWVR. The other group was tasked with directly interacting with the CWVR without building a system with SDVR (the Interaction, comparison group). Students' mental models of the cooling water system in CWVR were evaluated following completing the interaction experience with CWVR. The results demonstrate that the causal model notion of the mental model of the cooling water system was significantly higher in the Design, experimental group. The results suggest that designing a rich IVR application that facilitates constructive-generative engagements may carry merit in informing student mental models of complex technical concepts.

Boosting Engineering Education with Virtual Reality: An Experiment to Enhance Student Knowledge Retention

“…The findings revealed that VR-based classes lead to a deeper understanding of the subject matter, offering a more realistic, dynamic, and engaging learning experience compared to traditional teaching methods. These results are consistent with similar studies [34][35][36][37]70]. The findings indicate that establishing a cognitive teaching and learning environment using VR leads to greater learning and knowledge retention among students compared to traditional teaching methods.…”

“…More than 90% of the responses had indices between 6 and 7. These results present positive and relevant impacts on student satisfaction, engagement, and attractiveness rates, as indicated by similar studies [17,34,36,[69][70][71][72][73].…”

“…For instance, a study found a 76% increase in satisfaction among dentistry students [34], while another reported a 4.28 motivation score (on a Likert scale of 1-5) for science students [37]. Additionally, VR was found to enhance engagement in training for industrial systems [36] and boost motivation in practical nursing studies [69].…”

“…Additionally, the utilization of traditional teaching methods in engineering classes, given the new technologies implemented in the manufacturing realm, may lead to lower learning rates and knowledge gaps [33]. Previous studies have shown positive impacts on learning [34,35] and on the satisfaction, engagement, and attractiveness perceived by students subjected to VR approaches [36,37].…”

Emerging Dynamics of ChatGPT in Academia: A Scoping Review

“…Artificial intelligence in academia has evolved significantly, marking a pivotal moment in its development. Most prominent applications include grading and tutoring, analysing educational data, and using VR and AR technologies for immersive learning experiences and Generative AI and Large Language Models (LLMs) for generating text, translating languages, writing creative content, and answering questions (Slezaka et al, 2023). AIpowered apps have introduced a personalised teaching and learning process (Rudolph et al, 2023a) that identifies students' strengths, weaknesses, interests, and preferred ways of learning (Chan, 2023).…”