Examining the disjunctures between policy and care in Canada’s Parent and Grandparent Supervisa

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to examine disjunctures between the ways in which Canada’s Parent and Grandparent Supervisa is framed within policy documents and press releases, and how it is actually experienced by older adults and their adult children from the Global South who engage in intergenerational care exchanges once they reunify. Design/methodology/approach – A case study involving qualitative interviews with a married couple (adult children), and official texts from Citizenship and Immigration Canada were analyzed, and subsequently categorized according to themes. Findings – The findings of this paper first demonstrate how policies such as the Parent and Grandparent Supervisa and the revamped Family Sponsorship program are ostensibly made to alleviate the significant backlog of family reunification applications, but in reality streamline and categorize older adults from the Global South as visitors who are given minimal state entitlements. Second, the Parent and Grandparent Supervisa reinforces forms of structured dependency by placing the responsibility and burden of care onto sponsors who must provide financial, social, and health care to their older parents. Finally, official statements on the Parent and Grandparent Supervisa and restructured Family Sponsorship program ignore the complex intergenerational exchanges that take place to ensure the survival of the family unit. Research limitations/implications – Given the nature of the case study’s design, the study’s findings speak to the experiences of Analyn and Edwin; adult children who sponsored an older parent under the Parent and Grandparent Supervisa. Given the recency of the program, the issues highlighted provide a much-needed starting point in examining the Supervisa’s impact on families from the Global South. Moreover, future studies could critically assess how the highly gendered nature of care is experienced under Canada’s temporary reunification programs. Practical implications – The study highlights the everyday challenges of sponsoring a parent under the Parent and Grandparent Supervisa. These issues are particularly important for policy makers and practitioners to assess and understand how such policies transform dynamics of care for families from the Global South. The unbalanced power dynamics raises questions on how to best support overburdened adult children, and vulnerable older parents who have no access to state resources. Originality/value – The findings of this paper further the understanding of how families from the Global South provide and receive care under the Parent and Grandparent Supervisa. These experiences, however, are neglected within official state policies which frame older newcomers as visitors who are managed, and denied entitlements to state resources. Revealing disjunctures between policy and lived experiences can assist service providers, professionals, and policy makers to recognize how programs like the Parent and Grandparent Supervisa overburden the family unit, and exacerbate conditions of poverty and marginalization.

Access to health care among racialised immigrants to Canada in later life: a theoretical and empirical synthesis

“…This situation is more severe for recent aged immigrants who were sponsored by their families as they are ineligible for government assistance during the 20-year sponsorship period (Koehn, 2009). Studies have found that less than half of late-life family class immigrants via the Parent and Grandparent Sponsorship Program receive employment income (Ferrer, 2015) and low average earnings (Government of Canada, 2014), which institutionalise financial barriers to care.…”

Caregiving Across International Borders: a Systematic Review of Literature on Transnational Carer-Employees

“…However, the financial requirements and investment from adult children as sponsors penalize low-income households (Spitzer et al, 2006 ). Ferrer has argued that the streamlined super visa program “categorize older adults as ‘visitors’ who must be surveilled and made ineligible for state benefits because of common perceptions that they consume valuable and scarce resources” ( 2015 , p. 264). Even if parents are granted a visa to Canada, they are expected to buy health insurance.…”

The impact of Super Visa on Chinese immigrant families' settlement in Canada

“…In addition, due to the temporary status, parents/grandparents are ineligible for state-provided services and entitlement, and all medical and other caring responsibilities are on the shoulders of immigrant family and/or their parents/grandparents (Ferrer, 2015).…”