Examining Perceptions about Mandatory Influenza Vaccination of Healthcare Workers through Online Comments on News Stories

Abstract

BackgroundThe aim of this study was to understand online public perceptions of the debate surrounding the choice of annual influenza vaccinations or wearing masks as a condition of employment for healthcare workers, such as the one enacted in British Columbia in August 2012.MethodsFour national and 82 local (British Columbia) Canadian online news sites were searched for articles posted between August 2012 and May 2013 containing the words “healthcare workers” and “mandatory influenza vaccinations/immunizations” or “mandatory flu shots and healthcare workers.” We included articles from sources that predominantly concerned our topic of interest and that generated reader comments. Two researchers coded the unedited comments using thematic analysis, categorizing codes to allow themes to emerge. In addition to themes, the comments were categorized by: 1) sentiment towards influenza vaccines; 2) support for mandatory vaccination policies; 3) citing of reference materials or statistics; 4) self-identified health-care worker status; and 5) sharing of a personal story.Results1163 comments made by 648 commenters responding to 36 articles were analyzed. Popular themes included concerns about freedom of choice, vaccine effectiveness, patient safety, and distrust in government, public health, and the pharmaceutical industry. Almost half (48%) of commenters expressed a negative sentiment toward the influenza vaccine, 28% were positive, 20% were neutral, and 4% expressed mixed sentiment. Of those who commented on the policy, 75% did not support the condition to work policy, while 25% were in favour. Of the commenters, 11% self-identified as healthcare workers, 13% shared personal stories, and 18% cited a reference or statistic.InterpretationThe perception of the influenza vaccine in the comment sections of online news sites is fairly poor. Public health agencies should consider including online forums, comment sections, and social media sites as part of their communication channels to correct misinformation regarding the benefits of HCW influenza immunization and the effectiveness of the vaccine.

Capturing the Patient’s Perspective: a Review of Advances in Natural Language Processing of Health-Related Text

“…Sentiment analysis/classification is a well explored NLP task, and, because of its particular suitability to large social media data and the availability of annotated resources (e.g., data from the SemEval task [123]), it has found applications in an assortment of inter-domain tasks. For example, recently, sentiment analysis/classification techniques have been applied to understanding user sentiments associated with drugs [124,125], including non-medical use of drugs [126] and vaccinations [127], treatments [111,128], and diseases [129].…”

Online public reactions to frequency of diagnostic errors in US outpatient care

“…While methods to analyze online news media commentary to explore public perceptions of health issues have only recently emerged [11–14, 31], we found they provided useful insights into patients’ perceptions of diagnostic errors.…”

“…Traditionally, surveys and interviews have been used to assess this type of data. However, recently, online commentary has been used to access public perceptions for health issues, such as influenza and vaccines [11–14]. This platform offers commenters an interactive space to anonymously post opinions and participate in discussions [15].…”

How is the Doctor Feeling? ICU Provider Sentiment is Associated with Diagnostic Imaging Utilization

“…Sentiment analysis is a branch of natural language processing (NLP) that combines text analysis and computational linguistics to assess the emotion or polarity of a piece of text (positive, negative, or neutral) [18]. Sentiment analysis has been used widely in non-healthcare settings, such as social media [19] and newspaper publications [20] to identify and extract text-based sentiment. In the last few years this approach has also found application in the evaluation of healthrelated topics including health and happiness [21], health care satisfaction [22], and health care reform [23].…”