Examining investors' sentiments, behavioral biases and investment decisions during COVID-19 in the emerging stock market: a case of Pakistan stock market

Abstract

PurposeThis study investigates the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on investors' sentiments, behavioral biases and investment decisions in the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX).Design/methodology/approachThe authors have assessed investors' behaviors and sentiments and the stock market overreaction during COVID-19 using a questionnaire and collected data from 401 investors trading in the PSX.FindingsResults of structural equation modeling revealed that the COVID-19 pandemic affected investors' behaviors, investment decisions and trade volume. It created feelings of fear and uncertainty among market participants. Evidence suggests that behavioral heuristics and biases, including representative heuristic, anchoring heuristic, overconfidence bias and disposition effect, negatively influenced investors' decisions at the PSX.Research limitations/implicationsThis study will contribute to behavioral finance literature in the context of developing countries as it has revealed the impact of COVID-19 on the emerging stock market, and its results are generalizable to other emerging stock markets.Practical implicationsThe findings of this study will help academicians, researchers and policymakers of developing countries. Academicians can formulate new behavioral models that can depict the solutions of dealing with an uncertain situation like COVID-19. Policymakers like the Securities Exchange Commission and the PSX can formulate crisis management strategies based on behavioral finance concepts to cope with situations like COVID-19 in the future and help lessen investors' losses in the stock markets. The role of the Securities Exchange Commission is crucial as it regulates the financial markets. It can arrange workshops to educate investors to manage their decisions during crisis time and focus on the best use of irrational and rational decision-making at the same time using Lo (2004) adaptive market hypothesis.Originality/valueThe novelty of the paper is that the authors have introduced overconfidence and disposition effect as mediators that create a connection between representative and anchoring heuristics and investment decisions using primary data collected from investors (institutional and retail) to demonstrate the presence of psychological biases during COVID-19, and it has been done for the first time according to authors' knowledge. It is a contribution and addition to the behavioral finance literature in the context of developing countries' stock markets and their efficiency.

Overconfidence bias and stock market volatility in Ghana: testing the rationality of investors in the Covid-19 era

“…Shrotryia and Kalra (2021) examined the existence of overconfidence bias on emerging and frontier markets in the Covid-19 pandemic period and found evidence of overconfidence bias in the Covid-19 pandemic period. Similarly, Parveen et al (2021) revealed that the Covid-19 pandemic had an effect on the investor's behavior, investment decisions and trading volumes. Specifically, they reported that the biases, such as representative heuristic, anchoring, overconfidence bias and disposition effect, were observed to have a negative impact on investors' investment decisions at the Pakistan stock market during the Covid-19 pandemic period.…”

Nowcasting unemployment rate during the COVID-19 pandemic using Twitter data: The case of South Africa

“…This means that they were scared of the pandemic circumstances, yet hopeful that new solutions will be unearthed for prevention and recovery. Moreover, emotions regarding economy have been very negative during the COVID-19 pandemic (64,65). The study in (64,65) show that at the beginning of the pandemic investors became very fearful and uncertain of the stock market trends and trading.…”

Herd Mentality Amongst Equity Investors During COVID-19: Evidences from Saudi Arabia

“…Since the COVID-19 pandemic created dramatic uncertainty and panic among market participants worldwide (Ortmann et al, 2020;Talwar et al, 2021), few studies investigated the impact of such a pandemic on individual investor's behavioural factors. For example, Parveen et al (2021) investigated the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on individual investors' behavioural biases, sentiments and investment decisions in the Pakistan Stock Exchange via using a questionnaire from 401 investors. Parveen et al (2021) found that the COVID-19 outbreak influenced the investor's investment decisions due to the fear and uncertainty caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.…”

“…For example, Parveen et al (2021) investigated the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on individual investors' behavioural biases, sentiments and investment decisions in the Pakistan Stock Exchange via using a questionnaire from 401 investors. Parveen et al (2021) found that the COVID-19 outbreak influenced the investor's investment decisions due to the fear and uncertainty caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. They also found that the overconfidence bias and disposition effect negatively impacted investors' decisions.…”