Attention is a multifaceted mechanism operating on space, features, and memory. Previous studies reported both decline and preservation of attention in aging. Yet, it is unclear if healthy aging differentially affects attentional selection in these domains. To address these inconsistencies, we evaluated the ability to focus attention in a battery of 11 tasks in a large sample of younger and older adults (n = 172/174). We addressed if (1) aging effects are consistent across different attention tasks, and (2) if there is domain-specific or domain-general age-related decline in focused attention. Both younger and older adults benefited from focusing attention on space, features, and memory representations. Within the same domain, some tasks showed a decline, whereas others showed improvement with aging; and, on average, attentional benefits were similar across age groups. These results are inconsistent with the claim that aging is associated with either domain-specific or domain-general deficits in focused attention.