Examination of the New Short-Stay Nursing Home Quality Measures: Rehospitalizations, Emergency Department Visits, and Successful Returns to the Community

Abstract

In 2016, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) introduced 3 new quality measures (QMs) to its report card, Nursing Home Compare (NHC). These measures—rehospitalizations, emergency department visits, and successful discharges to the community—focus on short-stay residents. We offer a first analysis of nursing homes’ performance in terms of these new measures. We examined their properties and distribution across nursing homes using descriptive statistics and regression models. We found that, similar to other QMs, performance varies across the country, and that there is very minimal correlation between these 3 new QMs as well as between these QMs and other NHC QMs. Regression models reveal that better performance on these QMs tends to be associated with fewer deficiencies, higher staffing and more skilled staffing, nonprofit ownership, and lower proportion of Medicaid residents. Other characteristics are associated with better performance for some but not all 3 QMs. We also found improvement in all 3 QMs in the second year of publication. This study contributes to the validity of these measures by demonstrating their relationship to these structural QMs. It also suggests that these QMs are important by demonstrating their large variation across the country, suggesting substantial room for improvement, and finding that nursing homes are already responding to the incentives created by publication of these QMs.

Polypharmacy Management in Older Patients

“…Guidelines from the American Psychiatric Association give specific guidelines on the use of any antipsychotic medications in treating episodic symptoms of psychosis in patients with dementia. 73 Specifically, the guideline recommends comprehensive assessment and development of a treatment plan that addresses clear assessment of the risks and objectives for use. 73 The efficacy of antipsychotic medications has a very small literature base.…”

“…73 Specifically, the guideline recommends comprehensive assessment and development of a treatment plan that addresses clear assessment of the risks and objectives for use. 73 The efficacy of antipsychotic medications has a very small literature base. Treatment of behavioral issues in dementia with the LTC environment is limited to those exhibiting hazards to self or others.…”

Comparison of Consumer Rankings With Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Five-Star Rankings of Nursing Homes

“…What are the policy implications of these findings? The literature [3][4][5][6][7] has demonstrated that quality measures tend to be uncorrelated, and, hence, composite measures have to be constructed This suggests that a report card should include both types of summary measures, the one based on experts' opinion and that based on experienced consumers' preferences. Providing both would allow patients to compare them and, to the degree that they differ, decide whether they are more comfortable with the advice of an expert or another consumer.…”

“…2 Report cards that include a large number of quality indicators (QIs), which often are uncorrelated, provide mixed messages about the quality of each institution. [3][4][5][6][7] The mixed signals tend to be confusing for consumers. In fact, decision science recognizes that less is more when it comes to making choices.…”

Developing Age‐friendly Cities: Policy Opportunities and Challenges

“…Limited evaluation data exist on the impacts of this demonstration, but it has resulted in increasing the proportion of Medicare Advantage enrollees in the state to about 40%. The sum of these changes meant that for many residents, NH care was no longer long-term care, but rather a short rehabilitation stay as they transitioned back to the community (Saliba et al, 2018;Xu & Intrator, 2019).…”