Exact Solutions for the Entropy Production Rate of Several Irreversible Processes

Abstract

We investigate thermal conduction described by Newton's law of cooling and by Fourier's transport equation and chemical reactions based on mass action kinetics where we detail a simple example of a reaction mechanism with one intermediate. In these cases we derive exact expressions for the entropy production rate and its differential. We show that at a stationary state the entropy production rate is an extremum if and only if the stationary state is a state of thermodynamic equilibrium. These results are exact and independent of any expansions of the entropy production rate. In the case of thermal conduction we compare our exact approach with the conventional approach based on the expansion of the entropy production rate near equilibrium. If we expand the entropy production rate in a series and keep terms up to the third order in the deviation variables and then differentiate, we find out that the entropy production rate is not an extremum at a nonequilibrium steady state. If there is a strict proportionality between fluxes and forces, then the entropy production rate is an extremum at the stationary state even if the stationary state is far away from equilibrium.

Is the catalytic activity of triosephosphate isomerase fully optimized? An investigation based on maximization of entropy production

“…The maximum entropy production principle, or MaxEP conjecture [23], has long been neglected in physics, mainly due to lack of recognition that the principle of least dissipation [24,25] is in reality the application of the MaxEP principle when constraints are taken into account for linear relationships between fluxes and forces [26,27]. A tendency to elevate Prigogine's minimal entropy production theorem to the level of a general principle also contributed to confusion as noted by Ross and Vlad [28]. In fact, as Beretta and Martyushev stated [11,29,30], maximal EP implies minimal EP at some constrained stationary states such as the static head state for linear force-flux relationships.…”

Charged Brownian particles: Kramers and Smoluchowski equations and the hydrothermodynamical picture

“…Thus, even though Onsager relations are satisfied, the coefficient's dependence on nonequilibrium state variables and external fields, indicates that any variational principle associated with the entropy production [132,134,135,140,141], is not applicable to the present case [69,142] In the absence of the BGK reactive term, null magnetic field, and for the strictly stationary inhomogeneous bath case, we recover the inhomogeneous media advection-diffusion equation, presented by Ref. [96] and given by…”

Chiral polymerization: symmetry breaking and entropy production in closed systems

“…At equilibrium, the entropy production rate vanishes and is an extremum [32]. This production has been investigated recently for reversible versions of the Frank model [33,34].…”