Evolutionary implications of interspecific variation in a maternal effect: a meta-analysis of yolk testosterone response to competition

Abstract

Competition between conspecifics during the breeding season can result in behavioural and physiological programming of offspring via maternal effects. For birds, in which maternal effects are best studied, it has been claimed that exposure to increased competition causes greater deposition of testosterone into egg yolks, which creates faster growing, more aggressive offspring; such traits are thought to be beneficial for high-competition environments. Nevertheless, not all species show a positive relationship between competitive interactions and yolk testosterone, and an explanation for this interspecific variation is lacking. We here test if the magnitude and direction of maternal testosterone allocated to eggs in response to competition can be explained by life-history traits while accounting for phylogenetic relationships. We performed a meta-analysis relating effect size of yolk testosterone response to competition with species coloniality, nest type, parental effort and mating type. We found that effect size was moderated by coloniality and nest type; colonial species and those with open nests allocate less testosterone to eggs when in more competitive environments. Applying a life-history perspective helps contextualize studies showing little or negative responses of yolk testosterone to competition and improves our understanding of how variation in this maternal effect may have evolved.

On the relationship between body condition and parasite infection in wildlife: a review and meta‐analysis

“…v 2 , F, t, z, OR) into r (Wolf 1986;Borenstein et al 2009;Aloe & Thompson 2013). When test statistics were not reported, we simplified binary infection status to a contingency table and determined v 2 , calculated the standardised mean difference (Cohen's d) for intensity, or converted the p value to a standard normal deviate Z-score and used n to obtain r (Bentz et al 2016). We assigned negative values to r when infection was lower for hosts in better condition (or when infected hosts had poorer condition) and converted directional r into Fisher's Z (Zr; Borenstein et al 2009).…”

Planting gardens to support insect pollinators

“…When the value of test statistic was not reported, we followed Bentz et al. () and used the reported p value and sample size to calculate r . We assigned negative values to effect sizes for which the garden attributes significantly decreased pollinators (Viechtbauer ).…”

The developmental environment modulates mating‐induced aggression and fighting success in adult female Drosophila

“…Despite this, little work has investigated the potential role of the developmental environment in influencing female–female competition and levels of aggression (though see Cain & Ketterson, ; Cain & Langmore, for two observational field studies in birds). Hormones experienced during development have been shown to influence levels of both juvenile and adult aggression in a variety of bird species (Bentz, Becker, & Navara, ; Cordero, Ansermet, & Sandi, ; Müller, Dijkstra, & Groothuis, ). One study in the spotted hyena ( Crocuta crocuta ) found that females exposed to higher levels of androgens during gestation displayed higher levels of aggression as cubs (Dloniak, French, & Holekamp, ), which acts as a good indicator of success in adult competition to acquire social rank, leading to higher reproductive success (Holekamp & Smale, ).…”