Evidence on the magnitude of the economic, health and population effects of palm cooking oil consumption: an integrated modelling approach with Thailand as a case study

Abstract

Background Palm oil’s high yields, consequent low cost and highly versatile properties as a cooking oil and food ingredient have resulted in its thorough infiltration of the food sector in some countries. Longitudinal studies have associated palm oil’s high saturated fatty acid content with non-communicable disease, but neither the economic or disease burdens have been assessed previously. Methods This novel palm oil-focussed disease burden assessment employs a fully integrated health, macroeconomic and demographic Computable General Equilibrium Model for Thailand with nine regional (urban/rural) households. Nutritional changes from food consumption are endogenously translated into health (myocardial infarction (MI) and stroke) and population outcomes and are fed back into the macroeconomic model as health and caregiver-related productive labour supply effects and healthcare costs to generate holistic 2016–2035 burden estimates. Model scenarios mirror the replacement of palm cooking oil with other dietary oils and are compared with simulated total Thai health and macroeconomic burdens for MI and stroke. Results Replacing consumption of palm cooking oil with other dietary oils could reduce MI/stroke incident cases by 8280/2639 and cumulative deaths by 4683/894 over 20 years, removing approximately 0.5% of the total Thai burden of MI/stroke. This palm cooking oil replacement would reduce consumption shares of saturated/monounsaturated fatty acids in Thai household consumption by 6.5%/3% and increase polyunsaturated fatty acid consumption shares by 14%, yielding a 1.74% decrease in the population-wide total-to-HDL cholesterol ratio after 20 years. The macroeconomic burden that would be removed is US$308mn, approximately 0.44% of the total burden of MI/stroke on Thailand’s economy or 0.003% of cumulative 20-year GDP. Bangkok and Central region households benefit most from removal of disease burdens. Conclusions Simulations indicate that consumption of palm cooking oil, rather than other dietary oils, imposes a negative health burden (MI and stroke) and associated economic burden on a high consuming country, such as Thailand. Integrated sectoral model frameworks to assess these burdens are possible, and burden estimates from our simulated direct replacement of palm cooking oil indicate that using these frameworks both for broader analyses of dietary palm oil use and total burden analyses of other diseases may also be beneficial. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1186/s12963-019-0191-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Variability of Essential and Nonessential Fatty Acids of Irish Rapeseed Oils as an Indicator of Nutritional Quality

“…SFA are undesirable fatty acids associated with increased cholesterol in the blood. Literature has found that a specific cholesterol ratio to HDL in the bloodstream is a more precise heart disease indicator than just LDL concentration [ 30 ]. This study also stated that individual fatty acids could affect the ratio.…”

“…The USFA content of rapeseed oils accounts for approximately 90% of the fatty acid composition [ 22 , 30 ]. This was evident for rapeseed oils tested in this study.…”

Comparative characterization of vegetable oils from bulk suppliers/vendors in Nasarawa town market in Nigeria

“…Although many plant parts may yield oil, in commercial practice, oil is extracted primarily from seeds (Philip, 2022;Zhou et al, 2020;Ying et al, 2020;Purcaro et al, 2016;Kumar et al, 2016). Brahmi et al (2020); Keogh-Brown et al (2018) reported that vegetable oils are of great economic importance to human, industrially, vegetable oils are also used as ingredients or components in many manufactured products. Many other uses of ORIGINAL RESEARCH ARTICLE vegetable oils have been recorded by (Norzahir et al, 2019;Owuna, 2020).…”

Will More of the Same Achieve Malaria Elimination? Results from an Integrated Macroeconomic Epidemiological Demographic Model

“…Studying the effect of these interactions is as complex as it is important, and the bar to this kind of cross-disciplinary policy analysis has previously been the technical difficulty of integrating models which simultaneously capture all of these elements together with their dynamic feedback effects. However, previous applications of computable general equilibrium (CGE) models in the context of HIV/AIDS, 17 health co-benefits of GHD reduction strategies, 18 and dietary change [19][20][21] have advanced the level of complexity and use of these models in a health context, and the tool we developed for this study demonstrates that full integration of models is possible. Furthermore, its utility is illustrated in analyses of various scenarios for future economic growth and scaling up of interventions.…”