“…The tilt measured with respect to the horizontal can generally be of the order of a few degrees or less, on average, (e.g. Röttger and Larsen, 1990, and references therein; Larsen and Röttger, 1991;Palmer et al, 1991Palmer et al, , 1993Palmer et al, , 1998aChau and Balsley, 1998;Worthington et al, 1999aWorthington et al, ,b, 2000aKawano et al, 2001;Hobbs et al, 2000) or much more, such as 10 degrees in extreme cases, as reported by Worthington and Thomas (1997). Worthington et al (1999a,b) also found that the zenith angle where the maximum echo power was observed is more pronounced in the troposphere than in the stratosphere.…”